I like all three. I think I like the sheep soap the most. Maybe it's my mind just telling that. I used the Varen when it was in testing. I liked it and especially liked the fragrance.I see I'm a little late to the party, but I voted naked and smooth. When I was first starting out I bought a bunch of Stirling samples in different scents. Every sample worked great for shaving, but I never found a scent that I really liked. Since then, I've always had a tub of N and S. I do plan on trying the sheep and beeswax soon to compare.