Stirling’s Sheep - Legendary

[VEE86]

I recently ordered samples of all three unscented from stirling.

My experience with all of three unscented Stirling soaps, is that they make a creamy and slick lather and each gives a great post shave feel in their own way.
I ended up ordering a tub of both Naked & Smooth and Unscented with beeswax.
Even though The Unscented Sheep felt great for my skin I was not too fond of the Sheep smell.
I love to eat sheep but when I get to much of the fat I get a little unwell.
A little while after shaving using the soap with Sheep scent it reminds me of that.

 

[1e4]

Even though The Unscented Sheep felt great for my skin I was not too fond of the Sheep smell.
I love to eat sheep but when I get to much of the fat I get a little unwell.
A little while after shaving using the soap with Sheep scent it reminds me of that.

In case helpful, I've had good luck overcoming the smell by mixing Sheep with Eucalyptus Mint, and letting it air out in an open shave mug on the counter.

 

[BurnFree]

I got into the Beeswax version last year, and have used all 3, but over time, Stirling sheep has remained my solid favorite of the 3. It's just plain Slicker and lathers easier IMO. Post shave is more lanolin and less "waxy" (duh), but pretty equivocal by end of day. Scent preference aside, I have yet to use a bad Stirling product.

The strongly-scented mutton offerings are not personal favorites though- sheep must be difficult to work with.

I prefer to just Own the unscented Sheep in all it's Glory. Baa!!!
Ps. it really isn't offensive. YMMV.

 

[Tanuki]

Recently started picking up my Sheep (in stick form) more often. It is a performer! Beats MWF (old formula) by a wide margin.

 

[Jayson74]

Recently started picking up my Sheep (in stick form) more often. It is a performer! Beats MWF (old formula) by a wide margin.

I think I need to agree with you about it beating MWF. I love Mitchells but Sheep is a better shave...at least for me.
Jay

 

[sandstorm99]

Reading this thread has made me want to try/buy/sample V Stirling’s mutton tallow.
Question: do the Scott Pine Sheep and Electric Sheep have the same performance, lather and post-shave as the ‘unscented’ Sheep? Or is the Sheep simply superior to these two?

 

[Phoenixkh]

I will have to drag out my Unscented Sheep. I think I have one additional unscented tallow product.. I have to look. Maybe Naked and Smooth.... I love the Unscented with Beeswax. That's the only one of the three I've used.

 

[Omega48]

Sheep bath soap bars are excellent too.

 

[BurnFree]

Reading this thread has made me want to try/buy/sample V Stirling’s mutton tallow.
Question: do the Scott Pine Sheep and Electric Sheep have the same performance, lather and post-shave as the ‘unscented’ Sheep? Or is the Sheep simply superior to these two?

Yes, anything with "mutton" or "sheep" in the name is all the same formula. There is the unscented "SHEEP" and a handful of scented versions, some of which are seasonal/periodic.

Similarly, NAKED & SMOOTH is the unscented beef tallow formula that is used in most Stirling scented soap. NB: This recipe happens to also include lanolin, which is not the same thing as mutton tallow.

UNSCENTED WITH BEESWAX is a 3rd formula. It is beef tallow-based, but excludes almond oil & lanolin, adds beeswax, and tweaks the ratios of other ingredients. It has never been offered in a scented version to my knowledge.

 

[BurnFree]

Sheep bath soap bars are excellent too.

I like the Oatmeal Shea Butter (beef) and Scots Pine Sheep quite a bit.
Didn't like the Scots Pine shave soap as much - had a little different odor with the different recipe, although n=1 and could have been batch variation.

 

[Hairy Callahan]

Electric Sheep is one of my go-to shaving soaps. I'm scheduling my tub to be exhausted about the time Glacial Electric Sheep comes back online. Can't wait to kick it up a notch. But the Glacial version is seasonal and they took it off the website in August for the year.

 

[sandstorm99]

Yes, anything with "mutton" or "sheep" in the name is all the same formula. There is the unscented "SHEEP" and a handful of scented versions, some of which are seasonal/periodic.

great, thanks for the detailed response.
So the choice between unscented sheep, electric sheep, Scot’s pine sheep, Varen is down to scent preference, rather than performance, correct?

 

[BurnFree]

great, thanks for the detailed response.
So the choice between unscented sheep, electric sheep, Scot’s pine sheep, Varen is down to scent preference, rather than performance, correct?

Yes, that is correct!