Sig or Glock

[Jcarrier1990]

Trying to Choose between a Glock 43x, Sig p365 or Glock 19 Gen 4 or 5. I know these guns serve completely different purposes. But I’ve shot them all, liked them all but can’t decide which one to invest in? Opinions?

 

[Juddster]

If your going to carry go with the 365, its very easy to conceal and shoots great. G19 gen5 if your using as a home defense or range gun.

 

[Robini]

I will opt for a Sig over a Glock every time! Glock is a fantastic firearm but lacks the craftsmanship of a Sig IMO.

 

[nortac]

As you say, they serve different purposes. If you don't have something comparable to the Glock 19 in size and capacity, that is the one to start with, IMHO. All are winners in my book.

 

[nortac]

I will opt for a Sig over a Glock every time! Glock is a fantastic firearm but lacks the craftsmanship of a Sig IMO.

While I have and love my SIG 365, I don't think it's craftmanship is anything special. It is certainly not the craftmanship found in the larger, older, all metal SIGs.

 

[Pattorashu]

I adored my 226 in the service. My next pistol will be a Sig when I can afford it lol.

 

[Robini]

I have a standard 226 9mm, standard 229 40 caliber, and a 226 9mm from the custom shop. All are fantastic pistols. No complaints here.

 

[OkieStubble]

As you say, they serve different purposes. If you don't have something comparable to the Glock 19 in size and capacity, that is the one to start with, IMHO. All are winners in my book.

+1

 

[GeronimoWSB]

Try a cz

 

[shoelessjoe]

If your going to carry go with the 365, its very easy to conceal and shoots great. G19 gen5 if your using as a home defense or range gun.

What Juddster said — only thing I would add, and I know you didn’t ask , is that an HK P30SK will do any & everything those three pistols you mentioned can do & it will do them well. Be it a DA/SA or LEM with a 10, 13 or 15-round mag, the P30SK is an amazing weapon. And if it’s a striker-fired piece you’re wanting, well, have a look at an HK VP9SK.

 

[ackvil]

As you say, they serve different purposes. If you don't have something comparable to the Glock 19 in size and capacity, that is the one to start with, IMHO. All are winners in my book.

This.

 

[2Vu5_T]

Both. A 19 and a 226 in 9mm for me.

 

[Bhugo]

Oh just get it over with and buy all 3. Merry Christmas

 

[xiletero]

If you just want one, then G19 G5 MOS; all you will ever need and won't break down or betray you as the Sig might do.

 

[Acmemfg]

Glock 26. Another consideration. But..my 43X with a Sam Andrews Saddle Holster is pretty close to as good as it gets. A Milt Sparks Summer Special II if you must go IWB gets it all done.

 

[sneefy]

CZ PCR or P01.

Otherwise a G19

 

[nortac]

Bottom line is, the Glock 19 is the standard for medium sized, moderately high capacity 9mm pistols. It's the Goldilocks pistol, not too big, not too small, reliable as the day is long. It does what it's supposed to do every time. Not sexy, just right.

 

[Climb14er]

Sold all of my Sigs the past two years... P220 .45 ACP with Virgil Tripp Hard Chromed Slide, P226 Navy 9mm, P239 357 Sig... no longer wanted DA/SA. The Glock 19 remains. Might pick up a Sig P365... The DW CCO 1911 .45 ACP is my primary Carry. Have enjoyed keeping it simple!

 

[Ad Astra]

There's no wrong answer!


AA

 

[jar_]

I still have three Sig Sauers but no Glocks. But then I have very few polymer framed guns. I still almost always carry steel.