I agree 100%!!Since it’s already been resurrected, I don’t find the two similar at all. Proraso Red smells way better than Pinaud Vanilla and has far more depth; they’re different scent profiles anyway - Proraso is fresh, powdery sandalwood and Pinaud is mellow, powdered vanilla.
I just got Proraso and used it last night (had tried their green one). The smell of this one is almost identical to Pinaud Classic Vanilla that costs a fractionView attachment 1033794