I agree 100%!!Since it’s already been resurrected, I don’t find the two similar at all. Proraso Red smells way better than Pinaud Vanilla and has far more depth; they’re different scent profiles anyway - Proraso is fresh, powdery sandalwood and Pinaud is mellow, powdered vanilla.
To my nose Sandalwood and Vanilla are quite different in terms of scent. And these two splashes behave quite differently, too.