BIC's are my current favourite blades, but so far I've only use it in mild razors as it is very sharp! On my face, it gets sharper on shave two and sharper again on shave 3 so if you find it too sharp already, it might be worth trying it in a milder razor instead of chucking it?
My two razors are a Timeless .95 and the FOCS I recently got as a gift. I’ll try it next shave in the Timeless with the SB plate. If it doesn’t work, I have a couple blades that are fantastic in those razors. Luckily I only get a single tuck to try blades so won’t have a bunch sitting around if it doesn’t work. TBH, I was very excited about the Bic blade as many people like you say it is one of, if not their top blade. At least we have lots of choices