Here are size comparisons, the Beattie on the left is the first edition, the right one is the second edition. First 2 are nimrods, followed by the Rogers then the 55 zippo.
Larry
And here is the Rogers vs the zippo vs Beattie in size. The Beattie is thicker and a bit wider.
Larry
And here is the Rogers vs the zippo vs Beattie in size. The Beattie is thicker and a bit wider.