A list of Bay Rums without clove and cinnamon with real Carribean bay essence (Pimenta racemose), not the artificial stuff. Please
Based on your description, I think you would be pleased with any of the following Bay Rum producer's products:
Captain's Choice
Fine
Thor's Hammer
Grand Bay
To my nose, these are simply straight forward Pimento Racemosa Bay Rums without any twists or turns...no added cinnamon, no added citrus notes, no extra clove or nutmeg, etc.