I just bought this mutton tallow soap and used it the other day. Had an amazing shave with it and it seemed to me that it may have lathered a bit better than stirling beef tallow shave soaps. It's a mild piney scent. Nothing offensive. Kinda reminds me of stirling's christmas even beef tallow soap which I also have. The only other mutton tallow I have is electric sheep in glacial and this is a fantastic scent in my opinion. I also ordered stirling's frost drops which are supposed to add some cold to your shave. I used it and I didn't feel any cold. Maybe I have used these the wrong way. I lathered up my stirling soap onto my brush and than applied a few frost drops on top of the brush and I lathered on my face, but felt no cold. anyone else use these drops and did they work for them? The mutton tallow soaps are worth it.