Martin de Candre Nature might seem expensive initially but offers excellent value in the long run! Haslinger soaps are lightly scented and top tier performers.
Canada Shaving Soap is amazing and relatively new so not mentioned in this 2 year old thread. Fairly expensive but the stuff lasts forever. 175g for $41CAD.
Canada Shaving Soap - Canada Shaving Soap
canadashavingsoap.com