You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[SliceOfLife]

Hmm...

Speick
TFS
Custom

 

[mikej7193]

Mike's Orange, Black Pepper, and Cedarwood
Van Der Hagen Deluxe ( haven't tried luxury )
Arko


Haven't tried a whole lot else. I love that I can melt the VDH and add scents, but I wish it performed closer to Mike's.
And Arko smells great and performs well.

 

[Nick Danger]

Easy choice for me:

QCS
Mystic Waters
Mike's

All unscented. Great performers, very kind to my sensitive skin.

Nick

 

[CryptoDave]

Not in any particular order:
MWF
Tabac
EM's

 

[edgerunner]

I can narrow them down to 3 only by cheating:
1. MWF
2. DRH (Almond, Marlborough, Windsor)
3. Tabac

 

[TBoner]

Valobra
Palmolive
Arko

 

[Gustav]

Tabac
SIM
Joris

 

[FonGu]

MdC
Almost any Razorock
Something from Mike's, I just haven't zeroed in on a favorite scent yet

 

[mctmatt]

Klar Kabinett

La Toja Shave Stick

Institut of Karite

 

[sharpen]

For my part (these are all recent purchases due to AD) :

Proraro Green

Any GFT Basically

MdC


The choice was hard tough!

 

[SamF]

Cella
Arlington
MWF

 

[njpaddy]

A slight change from last year's post. Top 3 this year are:

1. DRH (any scent but Marlborough)
2. GFT Rose
3. Ogallala Bay Rum

If there were a #4, it would be Mike's Hungarian Lavender.

 

[TallyShave]

Right now...

Calani
Cella
Klar Seifen

 

[Taborcarn]

At the moment I'd have to say:

Mike's Natural Barbershop
DR Harris Arlington
Cella

 

[SevereWX]

Tabac
D.R. Harris Lavender
Proraso (green)

 

[Antique Hoosier]

Martin de Candre
Tabac
Mike's Hungarian Lavender

 

[buca3152]

TOBS sandalwood, T&H unscented and Williams. I would need the Williams to appreciate the other 2.

 

[maich]

Pdp
mwf
c&s 88

 

[JCturboT]

Easy one.

1.Mitchell's Wool Fat-great face feel during and after the shave.
2.Mike's Barber shop-almost as good as the Fat-almost.
3.Lea shave stick-slightly behind the first two but still a fantastic soap.

Jeff

 

[chrisf8657]

I pick 2:
Cella
Mike's Natural