You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[Galengwath]

MdC
D.R. Harris
Not sure what my third would be right now, but probably an artisan soap of some variety.

 

[eyesofgrey]

Mike's coconut
Arlington
Valobra Stick

 

[Evbo]

3 soaps? Only 3!? Forget it -- I couldn't do it. But if I absolutely HAD to do it, my choices would prob be:

Vintage Yardley - love the smell & the performance
Mike's Natural Soaps - Orange/Cedarwood/Black Pepper - scent & performance
QCS - Mysore Sandalwood croap - scent & performance

 

[dundak]

Tabac, MWF and Arko

 

[Coler]

In no particular order, Mitchell's Wool Fat, Mike's Orange & Cedarwood & Black Pepper, Tabac.

Those would serve me very well.

 

[Fatboy]

Tabac, Arko and Cella.

 

[nwjs]

I don't have a herd but if I had to make a list...

1. Saponeria Artigiana - Sapone da Barba Vegetale alla Mandorla (an Italian soft soap), which is my current one,
2. Speick stick
3. Probably Valobra Mandorla.

Although this could change at any time in the future, I could shave happily to the end of my days with any of these.

 

[FlyingGuillotine]

MdC, Vostok and Tabac

 

[rxonmymind]

That's what I have, all I have in my rotation. Great title!
MDC
Proraso
Halslinger Sheep milk & lanolin (don't have it yet but incoming from WCS!) Prior to this I had Almod. SO done with almond. No more. Nada, zilch, it's kaput.

Ok, so technically I have two & some thumb size samples from long ago.

 

[Memphis]

I only have 3 right now

GFT violet
D.R Harris & Co. Windsor and Marlborough

 

[Arcadies]

Mike's Natural Barbershop
Mike's Natural Rose & Cedarwood
Proraso Green in the tub

 

[Polerouter]

Tabac
Palmolive EU
Irisch Moos

 

[Yuritau]

Tabac
Arko
______

 

[mcgils]

MdC
MWF
C&S Oxford and Cambridge

 

[wksimple]

1. Palmolive stick
2. Palmolive stick
3. Palmolive stick

 

[Beezerpuppy]

Mitchell's Wool Fat
Institut Karité
DR Harris Arlington

Pure Awesomeness!!

 

[SafetyRZRBgnr78]

MWF
Mama bear Andy's mint
RazoRock Chianti lavender

 

[ItsAllGravy]

MWF, Vitos Coconut & Lea Shave Stick.

That was easy as those are the only soaps I will replace when they run out

 

[oc_in_fw]

1. Palmolive stick
2. Palmolive stick
3. Palmolive stick

I am in love with that stuff right now.

 

[Rushman2112]

I only have three at the moment: MdC, DR Harris Arlington and GFT Limes. The Limes is nearly finished, but I still have another puck that I got at the same time as the wooden bowl original.

If I ever finish these, I would definitely replace the MdC and DRH, but I might try a different third soap.

Funny seeing this almost a year on: I have Cade in the mix now and it may well have edged Limes out of the picture.