Same here. Specifically the Clubman Hair Tonic.
Which are the best Barbershop Scents?
- Thread starter Doc Dan
- Start date
I like the B&M Seville a lot, but I LOVE the "Antica ricetta" Bignoli amazing scent and protection.
I didn't need to know this!
^^^^^^^^^^ Phew. Sold out 
Like many, I have a barbershop affliction and the collection keeps growing... Seville / The Master / Barr Barr. I have enjoyed all of them about 5 times each and prefer them in that order. None of them are bad.
The Master and Barr Barr are both spicy compared to Seville, but there was something sweet about Barr Barr that I could not place my finger on. Cloves? Ginger cookies?
And then it hit me square in the nose when lathering Barr Barr last night.
Root Beer.
The Master and Barr Barr are both spicy compared to Seville, but there was something sweet about Barr Barr that I could not place my finger on. Cloves? Ginger cookies?
And then it hit me square in the nose when lathering Barr Barr last night.
Root Beer.
B&M Seville
Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber
Mike Natural Soaps Barbershop
Zingari Man Wanderer
Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber
Mike Natural Soaps Barbershop
Zingari Man Wanderer
I'm a big fan of WSP Rustic Barbershop. Haven't used it in a while, but man it's gooood.
I use the Formula T version, but WSP’s Barbershop is one of my absolute favorite soaps. The scent and the performance are both top notch. Their prices are out of control lately, but it’s good stuff.
Muhle Sandalwood soap
Fine American Blend reminds me of Barbershops
I'm going to throw out one that's another take on the barbershop theme. MacDuffs soap should be on every guys radar if not already in their den. A soap base that is top tier and wonderful scents.
Liked it so much I bought it as an aftershave to replace my finished off GST
This has become my favorite scent in all of wet shaving.
I have never heard of this company before. Canadian which I like. It's good soap?
MacDuffs Soap Company can compete with the best of them, IMO. Excellent base that makes a slick, Greek yogurt like lather. Their scents are around a 6/10 in strength and mostly abstract. I find their scents very pleasing and the post shave skin care lasts 12 or more hours.
Added Old Strathcona to the line-up and it's instantly #1 of the Barbershops. Similar to Seville, with more complexity, and a better base. Seville smells fake beside Old Strathcona.
Current unofficial standings:
Old Strathcona (NR) -> Master (+1) -> Seville (-2) -> Barr Barr -> Fleur de France (NR)
Current unofficial standings:
Old Strathcona (NR) -> Master (+1) -> Seville (-2) -> Barr Barr -> Fleur de France (NR)
PAA Cad and red planet
- Thread starter
- #79
I like the smell of MdC Original, sort of spicy. It doesn't do well for a straight razor so I no longer use it.
That's odd, I get great straight shaves from Fougère and Vetyver.
