Looking back through my endless combinations of soaps/aftershaves/razors/etc SOTD pics, I can definitely say, I need my B&M Reserve Classic Aftershave. It's me in a bottle.
Honorable Mention:
Proraso Green
B&M Behold the Whatsis!
Fine L'Orange Noir
It's evolving for me... but now it's:
Proraso Green
Clubman
Ruezel
Weird thing is that I rarely use it after I shave (usually at night), my soaps are leaving my skin in good shape and I let the scent linger.
I like to use it in the morning as a bit of a wake me up.
I'm surprised that it ended up this way, however,
Captain's Choice Lime
is without a doubt the most reached for AS in my drawer and I am going to be sad when it runs out and I am on sabbatical. It is the only current AS I plan to repurchase. I might also expand into some of the other offerings from the captain.
Proraso Green (and now probably Red too)
Lucky Tiger AST
Speick
Barrister & Mann Reserve (probably the Classic scent)
Paco Rabanne Pour Homme AS
Aramis AS