What Pinaud Clubman Should I Try First?

[DoctorShavegood]

At this time of year the reserve, musk or original. Come spring it's lime sec.

 

[Fatboy]

Special Reserve.
Especially this time of year.
For weekends...if you spend any time at all outdoors.

+1

 

[Alphonse]

Original is pretty good.. i like to mix slightly with water in my palm. Smells like baby wipes to some people, but really is a sporting scent to me.

I'd also go for the BayRum. It's awesome IMO. I cut that too. Smells like atomic fireballs basically.

 

[eezee]

Well, I tried the original this morning. The jury is still out!

 

[wagstaff]

Well, I tried the original this morning. The jury is still out!

I felt the same way when I tried it. Basically that came down to, I can't dislike it as much as I think I do, given all the love it gets!
But it turned out I kinda did. I would've voted Garry's too, if I got here in time -- so you wouldn't have to commit to too large a bottle of any one thing. At least the price is not prohibitive of experimentation, even with the full sizes.