Top 5 Aftershaves?

[emwolf]

Well, of the ones I have and have tried
1. Pinaud Clubman
2. Captain's Choice North
3. Faberge Woodhue
4. Pinaud Lilac Vegetal
5. Avon Spicy

 

[Bbb34]

In no particular order

- Speick.
- Musgo Real Classic.
- TOBS Mr. Taylor and No. 74 Original.
- Midnight and Two Provence.

But every now and then, just for old time's sake, I'll splash some Denim "Original" on my face too.

 

[discerningbev]

Love Fine Snakebite, Stirling Barbershop, Stirling Baker St. and Clubman as well. Top 5 is hard. I need a top 10.

 

[Mr. Bonney]

Still trying new products, but as of now it's:
1. Avon Spice
2. Avon Everest
3. Aqua Velva Musk
4. Avon Oland
5. Mennen Skin Bracer

OK, my listing has changed somewhat.
1)AV Musk
2)Avon Spicy
3)Avon Leather
4)Clubman SR
5)Captain's Choice Co9T

 

[kluber]

I like simple ingredient stuff the best.

Favorites
1. Fine Accoutrements (any scent)
2. Stirling
3. Thayers WH original
4. TOBS sandalwood
5. Chatillion Lux (scents hit and miss to me).

 

[muiriddin]

Winter
Black Dragon Scale Polish
Stirling Piacenza Balm

Summer
Cryogen
Stirling Piacenza Splash

Anytime
Captains Choice North

And that does leave out some other favorites...

Sent from my P01MA using Tapatalk

 

[Uncas]

Aqua Velva Locion
Fine American Blend
Pinaud Clubman
Floid Vigoroso
Proraso Green

 

[SailFast]

Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum
Chiseled Face Summer Storm
Chiseled Face Cryogen
Reef Point Aviator
Gabels Original

 

[Shojingod]

Italian barber Amici
Pinaud Clubman original
RR Don Marco
Aqua Velval Sport (green)
Skin Bracer

Honorable mentions
RR Zi Peppino
Lise Watier Neiges pour Homme (special occasions only)

 

[Piker]

1.) Fine Lavender Pour Homme
2.) Myrsol Blue
3.) Blackship Grooming Thomas Tew
4.) Blackship Grooming The Black Rose
5.) Fine American Blend

 

[ask4Edge]

Update:

1) D.R. Harris Marlborough
2) D.R. Harris Windsor
3) Floris JF
4) Floïd Vigoroso
5) TOBS Sandalwood

 

[facetime]

Agua Lavanda Puig
Chatillon Lux - u pick
etc - undecided
etc - undecided
etc - undecided
There have been times when last 2 spots may have been filled by the likes of:
Floid
Alt Innsbruck
Musgo Real (Classic)
Floris (Santal)
Florida Water
and last but not least the now unobtainium
Master Bay Rum, - old formula - once available thru Sally Beauty Supply

 

[Tokyospike]

In no particular order:

Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber
Fine Santal Absolut
Captain’s Choice Cat o’ Nine Tails
Wet Shaving Products True Lavender
Floid Vigoroso

 

[Orangeman]

Work:
Clubman Original
Skin Bracer Original
AV
AV Musk
Dollar Store AV knock-off
Social:
Clubman Original
Special Reserve
Classic Vanilla
Jovan Musk
Lucky Tiger

 

[steelhead52]

Chatillon Lux - several
Captain's Choice - several
Wm. Neumann - several
Wholly Kaw - several
B&M - several
Chiseled Face - several

 

[Viseguy]

• Master Checker Flag
• Floïd Vigoroso
• The Veg
• Master Breeze
• Stephan's Bay Rum

 

[Tatuued1]

1. Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve
2. Reef Point Peerless
3. Pinaud Bay Rum

 

[Ron R]

1:Razorock Amici reminds me of my youth chewing pink bubble gum blowing bubbles=red grape fruit
2Proraso red sandal wood
3:FINE fresh vetiver
4:Razorock emperor
5:Nivea freshness aftershave- it not long lasting but its OK

 

[Mceuph75]

1. Barrister’s Reserve Spice
2. PAA Gondolier
3. Stirling Sandpiper
4. Wholly Kaw Fougere Bouquet
5. Proraso Green

Honorable Mention (balm)
-Ariana and Evans Post Shave Serum

 

[Fairwind]

Currently:

Grand Havana
Clubman Special Reserve
Lustray Draggon Noir
Clubman Original
Clubman Lime Sec