5? Are you crazy?
OK. I'll narrow it down to 5:
Nivea Sensitive
Proraso Balm (the old stuff in the clear bottle / green cap, whatever that's called)
Dollar Tree splash
vintage Avon - take your pick
8-way tie for 5th:
- Clubman
- Trumper's Skin Food
- Stetson
- Brut
- Old Spice for the scent but not the A/S properties
- Tabac for the scent but not the A/S properties
- Afta
- Aqua Velva Ice Balm
OK. I'll narrow it down to 5:
Nivea Sensitive
Proraso Balm (the old stuff in the clear bottle / green cap, whatever that's called)
Dollar Tree splash
vintage Avon - take your pick
8-way tie for 5th:
- Clubman
- Trumper's Skin Food
- Stetson
- Brut
- Old Spice for the scent but not the A/S properties
- Tabac for the scent but not the A/S properties
- Afta
- Aqua Velva Ice Balm