Top 5 Aftershaves?

[OkieStubble]

1. Spicey
2. Menthol
3. Smokey
4. Woodsey
5. Fresh

 

[G.W.]

1. Spicey
2. Menthol
3. Smokey
4. Woodsey
5. Fresh

Ha, that's the only way I could post a list in this thread, good thinking. I've tried a dozen times to come up with something, and the closest I could get was, like, my top 50.

 

[Nah]

1. Clubman original
2. Skin bracer
3. AV ice blue
4. Florida water
5. AV musk

 

[Andreassti1]

Floid Genuine
Floid Vigorso
Floid Sauve
Stirling Gentleman
Brut Orginal

 

[Littlemax]

Jade East
Stirling Orange Chill
Stirling Margaritas In The Arctic
Stirling Lime
Stirling Bay Rum

 

[BigJ]

Tough question. For me (subject to change tomorrow):
Pinaud clubman
OS classic
Speick
Floid vigoroso
Fine American blend

 

[Adam18]

Pinaud Clubman and Lucky Tiger ..... That's all folks !

 

[cryhavoc]

1. Spicey
2. Menthol
3. Smokey
4. Woodsey
5. Fresh

Well played Sir

 

[OkieStubble]

Well played Sir

 

[JRRIII]

My top 5 at the moment in no particular order

Fine Platinum
Myrsol F./Extra
Fine Snakebite
PAA Agharta
PAA Coconut Bay w/ Lime

 

[pbrmhl]

1. Anything Chatillon Lux
2. Anything PAA
3. Anything Wm Neumann
4. Derby City Chop Shop
5. Tabac

 

[jdp93]

In no particular order:
Floid Blue
Floid Vigaroso
Fine American Blend
Fine Platinum
Speick


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[MrMoJoe]

Proraso (Green)
Tabac
Ogallala Bay rum, Limes & Peppercorns
Speick
Floid Blue

But, dang it, that's leaving out some GREAT ones (and this list could look a little different a month from now)!

 

[velocityboy]

1. Captain's Choice Bay Rum
2. Captain's Choice Bay Rum
3. 4711
4. Aqua Velva Ice Blue
5. Lucky Tiger

 

[Cliff]

From left to right : Acqua Di Parma, Musgo Real, Meehan Bay Rhum, Creed Vetiver, (I forget, sorry - not used anymore) and my favorite JHL.
(No aftershaves, nothing on my face but moisturizer)

 

[NewishShoes]

I only use 3.

Anthony Shaveworks "The cool fix"
Best for when the air is dry, and my face is lacking moisture. Fantastic product though.

Reuzel Original. New product, but I never see it mentioned on here. Nice classic scent. Woody with a hint of Orange?

Dove Men Care. Best hydrating cream.

 

[RobW]

Lately, my own rankings look something like...

Speick
Captain's Choice Sandalwood
Myrsol Agua Balsamica
Skin Bracer
Pinaud Clubman

Myrsol F/Extra and Floid Blue are looking to crash the rankings though, ask again next week.

 

[Surgeon]

Italian barber amici
Old spice lime (india)
Old spice original (p&g usa glass bottle)
Proraso blue balm
Razorock evil eye wax

 

[Randall J]

In no particular order:

1. Ogallala Bay Rum
2. Pinaud Clubman
3. Aqua Velva
4. English Leather
5. Proraso Green

 

[Kurtis]

I'm a low scent with little staying power guy. My fav's are, in no particular order:

Swiss Pitralon
4711
Myrsol _ Metisol, Aqua Balsamica, Antesol, Formula K, Pink.
Le Pere Lucien - Lotion du Barbier
D.R. Harris Pink