Top 5 Aftershaves?

[discerningbev]

I do love Ogallala Bay Rum and Sandalwood as well. It is very strong and has immense staying power.

 

[ask4Edge]

Penhaligon's - Blenheim Bouquet

Floris - Santal

Taylor - Sandalwood

Harris - Sandalwood/Marlborough

Czech & Speake - No.88/Neroli

 

[Northstonehill]

1. Proraso Green
2. Myrsol Blue
3. Aqua Velva Ice Blue
4. Pitralon Classic
5. THE NEXT ONES I HAVEN'T FOUND!!

I really would like to find more, I have bought many, Always get disappointed...

 

[Quijote]

B&M Reserve Cool
B&M Seville
Stirling Gatlinburg
Stirling Piacenza
Captain's Choice Lime

 

[nwohio]

I do love Ogallala Bay Rum and Sandalwood as well. It is very strong and has immense staying power.

+1 One of my favorites!

 

[Cino]

Ogallala Bay Rum
- Sandalwood
- lime and peppercorns
- sage and cedar
CO9T
Fine Platinum
B&M Lavanille

I also like to doctor Fine AS(s) with Witch Hazel and EXTRA MENTHOL. Frostbite levels of freaking MENTHOL!

 

[kaizen]

Le Pere Lucien
Sun Up
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Musgo Real Classic
Razorock XXX

 

[ColonelHogan]

In terms of frequency of use, it's probably something like this:
Stephan bay rum
Italian Floid
Vitos Aftershaving
Gillette Sun Up
Proraso green

 

[Newmania]

Myrsol Antesol
Proraso Green
WSP Barbacool
Razorock Baby Blue
Barrister and Mann Cool

 

[Arjen]

In no particular order:

• Weleda balm
• Cella lotion
• Cella balm
• Proraso green
• Nivea lotion

 

[babydials]

B&M Classic Reserve
B&M Fougere
Beaver Woodwright Thomas Tam
Stirling Gatlinburg
Musco Real Classic

 

[August West]

DR Harris Sandalwood
Royall Lyme
West Indies Bay Rum
Myrsol Aqua Balsamica
Fine Snakebite

 

[mdmacdonald]

Chiseled Face Cryogen
Ogallala Bay Rum & Sandalwood
Fine Accoutrements Fresh Vetiver
Fine Accoutrements Platinum
Kramperts Frostbite

 

[cwsnc]

In no particular order:

Williams Aqua Velva Loción (imported)
Pinaud Clubman
Aqua Velva Musk
RazoRock Blue Barbershop
RazoRock XXX

 

[User 306]

This is hard but I'll give it a go... In no particular order

Fall & Winter
AOS Kingsman Burbon Amber
ADP Essenza
ADP Barbire
AOS Oud
TOB Sandalwood
RR Tuscan Oud

Spring & Summer
Stirling Iced Pineapple
Stirling Island man
4711
Thayers Cucumber and the Lemon
AOS Lemon

Anytime
Proraso Green
Proraso White
Stirling Executive man
Stirling Well Dressed man
Floid Blue
Old Spice Vintage
RR Emperor
AOS Lavender
Thayers unscented

 

[discerningbev]

Update:
1) Floid Vigoroso
2) Fine American Blend
3) Fine Lavender Pour Homme
4) Sudsy Soapry White Sage and Lime
5) Penhaligon’s Blenheim Bouquet

Honorable mention: TOBS Eaton College, TOBS Sandalwood, Fine Fresh Vetiver

 

[ask4Edge]

(Update)

1. GFT Limes
2. Blenheim Bouquet
3. D. R. Harris Marlborough
4. TOBS Sandalwood
5. Floid Vigoroso (Spain)

 

[shavefan]

Lucky Tiger
Myrsol Balsamica
Vitos
Proraso Sandalwood
CRSW moisturizing aftershave

 

[Thalasos]

Floid Mentolado Vigoroso
Pitralon Swiss
Florida Water
Acqua Velva
Speick

Floid is my second to none menthol and alcohol punch, breaking the dawn and coming to terms with daily life. Well, that's, actually, wet shaving inner secret.
But I will turn 60 next year and also will turn Weleda Boy at that time. ;-)

Sent from my MI 5 using Tapatalk

 

[SaintAndrewsAlumnus]

#1: William Neumann 1911

The Rest:
Floris No 89
Stirling Baker St
B&M Cool
Eton College

Honorable Mentions:
B&M fougere classique -- sad its gone
Cade splash --still have half a bottle for special occasions!