What's new

Portland General Whiskey Aftershave Balm

After about two weeks, I received my PGS Whiskey Balm. Excitedly tore open the packaging and first impressions were...not quite what I'd hoped for. You can't tell from the etsy pics, but the much raved about packaging is more "faux" vintage than actual. The bottle is cheap plastic meant to look like old medicine bottle glass and the label is a slick paper printed to look aged. It's funny how "faux" vintage design can actually be more of a turn off than slick, modern packaging--the lack of authenticity really bothers me. "Oh well," I said, "it only cost $25." Move on to the product.
The Whiskey scent is spectacular. It actually smells like a nice rye whiskey at the start and then softens up to become more woodsy and herbal. My girlfriend is nuts about it. What she's not so hot on (and neither am I) is the fact that the balm leaves my face looking like I just lathered myself in vegetable oil. In spite of the product's description as "non-greasy," I have to wash my hands with soap after applying. The ingredients are a variety of natural oils which I am sure are all wonderful for your skin, but also leave your face a little unsightly to walk into the office with. Granted I'm a morning person, but even applying as little as three drops gives a whole new meaning to "bright and shiny."
Ultimately, I figured out that mixing a few drops with a dab of non-scented lotion allows the balm to absorb much better (while letting you keep the great fragrance). As much as I like the smell though, I don't know if I'm going to want to keep buying a product that needs a workaround to work with.
 
This could be the discussion thread for your review.

Thanks for taking the time to write a review of a product that I am interested in.

The packaging intrigued me. I'm glad to know that the photos don't represent what the packaging really looks like. I would have never guessed that its in a plastic bottle.

A product that leaves my face greasy is a definite deal breaker.

The scent sounds great.
 
Thanks for the comments! That is interesting-I have been using her "Tabac" aftershave splash (she is actually changing the name to "Tobacco"), which does come in a glass bottle and is not greasy at all. I notice she also has a whisky aftershave splash, as well as the balm which you tried. I was thinking about trying the whisky, and she also just put out a limited edition sandalwood aftershave balm which looks pretty interesting, but it is good to know that you had greasiness issues with the balm, definitely something to consider. All in though I really like her products (I have tried the Tabac shave soap, aftershave splash and EdT) and her customer service is excellent-
 
Thanks for the great review. (Love your tag line: "Smell like Brando, Look like Crisco.") I'm posting here instead of in the review thread. Have you considered trying her Whiskey aftershave splash? I haven't tried any of her products myself, but I wonder if the splash might solve the shine issue for you, while still allowing you to enjoy the scent as an aftershave. Of course, as mentioned, the EdT is an option, too. I've thought about trying her Tabac soap and splash, but I haven't gotten around to ordering it yet. I think I'll avoid the balm, at least.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom