Old Spice has been my go to AS for over 50 years so it must be my best.
Worst: too many to count or remember
Worst: too many to count or remember
Best and worst aftershave purchase
- Thread starter Nah
- Start date
Best: Barrister and Mann Bay Rum
Worst: Black Magic Bay Rum
Worst: Black Magic Bay Rum
Best: Ogallala Bay Rum & Sandalwood, Dr. Jon's Runaway, Nivea sensitive skin balm (always a go-to especially for irritation), Proraso Red & Green, Clubman Pinaud
Worst: Nivea Deep Comforting (A forum post mentioned a pharmacy was selling it for 75% off, a real steal... but my local pharmacy was only selling it for 20% off. I bought it anyway, but the scent is kinda close to Gillette Cool Wave but not as good). I rarely use it and will probably PIF or trade one day.
Worst: Nivea Deep Comforting (A forum post mentioned a pharmacy was selling it for 75% off, a real steal... but my local pharmacy was only selling it for 20% off. I bought it anyway, but the scent is kinda close to Gillette Cool Wave but not as good). I rarely use it and will probably PIF or trade one day.
Best: Floid Black
Wosre: Ogallala Bay Rum. Way too strong!
Wosre: Ogallala Bay Rum. Way too strong!
Best Aftershave purchase : Southern Witchcrafts Samhain. Alcohol free love the scent and it feels good!
Worse Aftershave Purchase: Dare to Be Bald aftershave/moisterizer. Smells weird and fake aswell as having a lot of artificial ingredients and made my skin feel weird.
Worse Aftershave Purchase: Dare to Be Bald aftershave/moisterizer. Smells weird and fake aswell as having a lot of artificial ingredients and made my skin feel weird.
"Dare to be bald"... Lol. I'm already bald so that wouldn't work on me.
Best scent is the mono theme bourbon vetiver. The absolute worst for me had got to be....... English Leather. There I said it.
Does it have to be a purchase? I have received as a gift a year ago Axe Excite. At first I didn't mind the scent, even post feel is ok, however after few uses I started to hate that smell, just can't stand it. If I want to torture someone I would make him sniff that thing 24h a day.
Best, sounds odd, but Nivea Sensitive aftershave balm, that green stuff. I just love it.
Edit: smells like a high school changing room after PE. I'm 25, so my high school wasn't so long ago.
Best, sounds odd, but Nivea Sensitive aftershave balm, that green stuff. I just love it.
Edit: smells like a high school changing room after PE. I'm 25, so my high school wasn't so long ago.
I am gonna go with this. Love clubman. Tried the veg for the first time tonight. Like a cat sprayed in a funeral home full of dead old ladies. Schwew. Proly ougjta try it a few more times ro be sure.
LMAO! The less morbid description would be, cat spray & formaldehyde with a hint of blue hair dye.
And lol'd @ 'proly ougjta'. 
Best: Probably PAA Oubliette
Worst: Pinaud Clubman Classic Vanilla
Worst: Pinaud Clubman Classic Vanilla
Wow, Pinaud Clubman Classic Vanilla the worst...
Best : Many including SV Desert Vetiver but if I had to pick one it would be Tabac. Simply great. Addicted to the scent, brides approved and great postshave. ( Only using it combined with tabac soap)
Worst : None yet, I rotate through all my AS. If I had to pick the "least" good would be proraso red because I think I might be allergic to something in it that causes redness.
Worst : None yet, I rotate through all my AS. If I had to pick the "least" good would be proraso red because I think I might be allergic to something in it that causes redness.
Mispelled. Should be "oughta"LMAO! The less morbid description would be, cat spray & formaldehyde with a hint of blue hair dye.
tankerjohn
A little poofier than I prefer
Best: I guess its gotta be Proraso Green. I've gone through more bottles of that juice than anything. Love it!
Worst: Tough call, but I think I have go with Brut. Crazy, right? I wanted to like it since I love Clubman and fougere/barbershop scents in general. But there is just something in the scent profile that put me off and gave me a headache every time I used it. No bueno.
Worst: Tough call, but I think I have go with Brut. Crazy, right? I wanted to like it since I love Clubman and fougere/barbershop scents in general. But there is just something in the scent profile that put me off and gave me a headache every time I used it. No bueno.
