Best and worst aftershave purchase

[crleftwich]

Best:

• Fine, American Blend
• Aqua Velva Ice Sport
• Pinaud Clubman, original and vanilla

Worst:

• Macho (not sure who the maker is, bought at Big Lots)
• Lilac Vegetal - I tried to like it but just really couldn't.

 

[FireDragon76]

Best: Nivea Sensitive Cooling balm, Rose of Bulgaria balm, Dickenson's Hydrating Toner
Worst: Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum. Barbasol Brisk

 

[P-51G t]

Best would be Ogallala limes and peppercorn

worst is pinaud lilac vegital

 

[Marciano]

Never recommended in this blog I think but after tried a lot over the years my best ever aftershave is definitely korres ginseng and marigold
It’s best in terms of scent,luxurious feel on the skin,cool down instantly after the shave and it’s alcohol free I remember.
Found this link online from mankind KORRES Natural Men's Ginseng and Marigold After Shave Cream 200ml - https://bit.ly/2QoKNKF

 

[guitarslinger]

Best: b&m behold the whatsis!
Worst: clubman special reserve. Splashed it on myself at a 70’s party. Took off my costume. Wretched.

 

[MntnMan62]

Best: Pinaud Clubman
Worst: Lilac Vegetal

 

[Dolebob]

Best balm: Nivea (nice scent), Arko Cool (works!!)
Best splash: Reuzel, Suavecito Whiskey Bar

Worst balm: Proraso Wood & Spice (gave me a head ache)
Worst splash: A Belarusian aftershave called "Brutal". Holy **** it smells like an old soviet cafe, literally makes me smell like a tobacco smoker. It's so weird. Very brutal, and nauseating.

 

[raccoonandbrush]

Best: Floid Blue
Not the best: Clubman Original


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Orangeman]

Best. Clubman SR.

Worst. AV Sport honestly tried to like it but no go. Jovan Musk, scent makes my throat scratchy, dont know what the deal is here exactly.

 

[mrlandpirate]

Best: La Rive Cabana
Worst: midnight stage witch hazel old campfire smell

 

[lampm10999]

Best would be maol grooming. Worst would be lather n shave co off amazon. Great scent but oily

 

[something better]

Fine green vetiver

 

[EclipseRedRing]

Best - vintage Faberge Brut (before it became Brut 33), Shulton OS, Yardley Black Label, Yardley Gentleman, Tabac EDC.
Worst - Tabac EDT (awful, smells nothing like Tabac).

 

[Stubblebum]

Best: Stirling Sandpiper

Best for the $: Barbasol Brisk, vintage Avon (all), Clubman

Worst: Clubman Special Reserve

 

[Boghopper]

Best - scent wise it’s Fine AB

Worst- proraso red. I like Sandalwood but oooh I hated this. Piffed it right away. Smells like cheap dollar store cologne.

 

[Will DDH]

Best quality: Maol Grooming

Best scent: A+E Signature

Worst: TBD (been lucky enough to enjoy all my aftershaves for both quality and scent!)

 

[BJJ Shaver]

Worst: Captain's Choice Lime and Fine Fresh Vetiver - the only two I threw out.
Best: Impossible. Depends on my mood... if I have to choose then maybe RazoRock The Stallion or Floid Black or PAA Cavendish or...never mind.

 

[RigelDust]

Best - WK King Of Oud
Worst - Lisa’s Isle of Skye AS Balm smelt like an antique shop. I can’t even rate the effectiveness because the “scent” was so awful.

 

[The situational shaver]

For winter:
Best-clubman musk
Worst-col. Conks’ bay rum (it’s good, just a little expensive for what it is).

 

[Leo501]

Duke Cannon Ice Cold. Not necessarily the Best AS, rather something I picked up on a whim and fell in love with. For years I'd only been using Nivea unscented sensitive skin balm, so Duke started me on a journey of exploration and I'm up to about a dozen different AS.

Best- Ogallala Bay Rum & Sandalwood - Love the scent and the texture of the oils, quite different from balms and splashes.

Worst- nothing yet