Not sure about the croap thing but it's definitely the best value soap. There's soaps I get better lathers with or are slicker but not at the outstanding price point of Stirling. I've got 8 Stirling soaps and throughly enjoy every one of them. Their soaps inspired by fragrances are very close to the original scent.
stirling soap
- Thread starter jonwilson
- Start date
- Thread starter
- #22
I have a number of Stirling soaps, more than half are their mutton tallow base...one of my top performing soaps. Thanks, @Hannah's Dad !
Adore my MiTA soap and balm and just received the creamy coconut balm and it smells darn nice! I hear the mutton tallows are slicker? I will try those next.
Stirlings aftershave splash and balm are outstanding as well.
One of my favorites. I was hooked the first time I tried a sample. I love a licorice scent and it has just the right amount of menthol for me. Hopefully, it checks all the boxes for you.
I've just the 1 at the moment Executive Man with the matching AS and balm but it won't be my last thats for sure.
Stirling makes a great soap with a scent for just about everyone. Currently I'm enjoying Baker Street soap and splash.
Has anyone tried the Stirling Green? I am curious as to how close they got to the old green bottle polo.
Rhody
I'm a Lumberjack.
I’m toying with the idea of buying a soap puck instead of a tub. I noticed there’s a significant savings. Theoretically if I actually finish a tub I could clean it out and pop in the replacement puck. Anyone do that?
Hannah's Dad
I Can See Better Than Bigfoot.
That makes Stirling an even better value, IMHO.
There are a few threads in the Soap section of the forum that can answer this question... Just use the search function for that forum.
It will work with the larger tub. You may have to smash the edges outward to fill the tub as I believe the puck is a smaller diameter and made to fit in the smaller 4oz tub that they sell.
I think you are spot on correct bmy friend! I got 5.8 ounces of Stirling in the Black Cherry
variety. Cost me only 19 dollars with shipping included.
IMO, best deal ever for soap this good. Smells delicious, and performance is excellent.
And like you said, you get a lot of it.I also know what you mean by other artisan soaps. Caties Bubbles for example, 4 ounces only, tub is not filled to the top!
Stirling is awesome
Rhody
I'm a Lumberjack.
Thanks much for pointing this out. I didn’t see that the puck is 4.5 oz compared to 5.8 with the jar.
To me the Stirling soaps have the same consistency as Cella Extra Purissima in the large block form
and loads the same for me too.
I think that style is called Italian Cream soap. I bit harder than a P.A.A. soap for instance
that I consider a croap. ?
and loads the same for me too.
I think that style is called Italian Cream soap. I bit harder than a P.A.A. soap for instance
that I consider a croap. ?
- Thread starter
- #36
I think you are spot on correct bmy friend! I got 5.8 ounces of Stirling in the Black Cherry
IMO, best deal ever for soap this good. Smells delicious, and performance is excellent.
I also know what you mean by other artisan soaps. Caties Bubbles for example, 4 ounces only, tub is not filled to the top!
Stirling is awesome
those soaps are awesome. I got the lemon chill and black cherry glacial shave soaps. Both incredible and both have a cooling kick to them.
I would say it’s as close to Polo Green as a shaving soap can get. Great scent, with decent longevity. I have the soap, splash, and balm … awesome!
Thanks. I pulled the trigger and have some on the way. Soap, splash and balm!
Wondering how you are liking Stirling Green?
I tell you what, Stirling Glacial Lemon Chill is an amazing soap too. I think their Black Cherry has a strong scent still, but the Glacial Lemon Chill provides the cool, you need for summer. I recommend it as well!
