Any recommendations for a orange or citrus scented shave soap with good cushion? I use Cremo as my pre-shave for slickness, so I want something that will not clash with it.
MdC Agrumes is very nice (lemon, grapefruit, bergamot). Second, the Fine rec. It's a cream, but the SJoL Orange/Patchouli is very nice. B&M Latha Limon, if you can find any, which IIRC has some orange in it.
I'm really enjoying Jerry Stark's 'Vegan Orange and Vanilla', but one of the things that I like about it is the low cushion. So it may not work for the OP.
I will second the vegan WSP Citrus Blast - nice scent. WSP does not seem to make their Formula T soap in this scent.
I had some Mike’s Orange, Cedarwood & Black Pepper that I became tired of. So I mixed it with some of Mike’s Vetiver. And, voila, the combination is awesome. Hands down my favorite orange scented soap!