Seville is probably the one i love the most. The oakmoss in the back end is what makes me keep going back to it. My tub in excelsior has a few more shaves left but it's pretty close to 3017 then i'll be ordering a new tub in the new softheart base probably over the winter.
I also love Fern in the Reserve base. Classic barbasol/fougere scent. Hard to believe Fern doesn't get more love.
42 has been in my top 3 since it came in the Glissant base. Yeah that's a long time. But Passiflora is quickly approaching that status now. Love it. So many great soaps and scents. Leviathan, Fougere Gothique, FMOM, Seville, LGC... the list goes on and on.
I've tried a bunch of new soaps since my last post here. I think Leviathan is my #1 at this point. I'm not quite sure what #2 would be- either Seville or 42- they are close contenders.