You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[Limekiln]

MdC
Arko stick
Proraso Green tub.

And funny enough, these are the only ones I have. So I'm already reduced, and happy as a clam.

 

[Razorsnake]

Cella, Ogallala bay rum and Tabac

 

[DimeBlade]

Razorock XXX
Mike's Barbershop
Strop Shoppe Baker Street

 

[Telefan]

Please allow me five:

Cella
RazoRock Artisan
Valobra stick
Martin de Candre
La Toja

Marco,

I'd thought your list would be:

1. Cella
2. Cella
3. Cella
4. Cella
5. Cella

I just ordered my first red tub of Cella today, can't wait to get it!

Joe

 

[Sniffman]

1. D.R. Harris Arlington (a cheaper substitute for Acqua Di Parma; I used to have the original run of RazoRock XXX which I swear was the even cheaper alternative to Acqua Di Parma, but this is no longer in production)

2. Cella

3. TOBS Sandalwood

 

[Gilles77]

1. Castle Forbes Lime. Its fantastic smell and lathering ability.
2. Tabac Soap in any format. It was my father's fragrance...

3. Valobra Almond soft shaving soap. Simple composition, great smell, and easy to stick in any container.

 

[Lifes a Peach]

1. MWF

2. Mikes Natural Soaps (any)

3. Speick soap stick

 

[Scaramouche]

1. B&M Bay Rum
2. GFT Violet
3. Tabac

 

[Pepin]

1. Proraso Green
2. GFT Eucris
3. Dr. Harris Marlborough

 

[KW Driver]

No.... I won't play this game...



Sorry....

Concur.

 

[Townyj]

Irisch Moos
Valobra
Arko

 

[evnpar]

Boellis Panama 1924
Wickham Super Smooth
Le Père Lucien

 

[JasonNYM]

1. Mystic Water(Lily of the Valley)
2.Proraso Green
3.WSP Rustic Barbershop

 

[grantmm]

AOS Sandalwood - Tallow
MdC brain bowl
B&M - Fougere Imperiale tallow

 

[wagstaff]

Mike's Vetiver
Strop Shoppe SE (Russian Tea)
MWF

But there are so many soaps I haven't even tried yet! (Sympathy elicited? No? Didn't think so).

 

[gwgrooms]

So far...

Tabac
Arko
Cella

BUT Razorock XXX and Strop Shoppe SE Tallow Baker Street are on the way.

 

[IMightBeWrong]

Man, that's tough. MdC Original is in there for sure, I don't know what else I would for sure keep, though.

 

[UKJim]

Easy choice....
1- MWW
2- Tabac
3- Proraso Green

Of course it is an easy choice.... Only ever tried a total of 7. (2nd division was Proraso red, TOBS & Arko. Only 1 complete reject - Musgo)

 

[AJ123]

Is anybody totaling or summarizing these entries?

 

[herbert7890]

Only 3??!!! Thats cruel stuff!!!

Caties Bubbles LPV
Barrister & Mann Leviathan
Mike's Natural Soap Barbershop