What's new

Wilkinson Sword vs Feather

WILKINSON SWORD RAZOR BLADES.jpg

Both of these manufacturers have a good reputation to uphold and are rightly respected here and the World over.

So I compared the two and found that Feathers are brilliant for 2-3 shaves max then they tug uncomfortably and have to go offski to the binski.
I have to use a consistent angle, smooth sweep and stable pressure otherwise they bite and can catch you out.

On some razors that clamp the blade well I can hear them start to bite and I reverse and go back with short strokes so I don`t get any nicks and weepers.

My very first shave with a Feather in my twenties - mid eighties time, I remember I got no nicks or redness just a little irritation that passed in a couple of hours - after that, I respected them more and approached them a different way to my run of the mill blades, being slightly slower and more cautious.

All my normal ones were just scrape and forget to me - I literally shave with my eyes shut in the bath listening to American Talk Radio podcasts - so no need for a mirror and I don`t need a brush - the dragon uses one on her legs etc. - Like the posh Yaqi tuxedo I surprised her with the other day.

I`ve learnt to use any soap over the years and being skint, I`ve had to improvise so I can use washing up liquid, shampoo, conditioner, washing liquid and powder, fabric conditioner (I wish I was kidding) and in the desert veg oil and booze - with an ancient cut-throat - so I`m not too fussy about soaps if good ones aren`t to hand; I can still manage a passable scrape.

In the heat, like in Cairo or Sharm in July where it`s 111 degrees at midnight my skin and nails grow faster and I need 2 shaves a day and 3 or 4 showers to assuage the dragon.
Alexandria is even worse for shaving and showering because of the humidity near the delta ; I prefer dry heat.

The Wilkinson Swords - especially my old ones are universally great with all my budget wonderful Chinese efforts and the pile of vintage cheapies I own.
Very smooth no rash or nicks and one blade does me for weeks - I`ve never counted accurately but defo more than ten.

I`ve got very resilient skin - never had spots as a kid and can survive hot sun abroad with no moisturiser and using just salad dressing - olive oil and vinegar as suncream - a la locals - I don`t burn I just go straight to brown thankfully.

So, to sum up I can use both brands but prefer the Wilki`s for shave and forget at any speed - with the Feathers I have to slow right down and be much more deliberate and accurate - like with an antique cut-throat - can`t remember the brands - it didn`t matter to me then - before I landed here.

Erm got 100 Wilkinsons coming early next week for £14 with 24hr courier dispatch - job`s a good `un.

I don`t care if they`re Chinese or Indian but prefer German going on past recollection of longevity and smoothness.

Oh brilliant, just read on the site that they`re German - yippee !
 
Last edited:
Feather is a unique blade and nothing else is quite like it (Excellent blade!). The German Wilkinson isn't as sharp as a feather (nothing is) but is sharp enough and will last me for 10+ shaves without losing much of that sharpness. Very smooth too.
I totally agree AndyPanda I think the Wilkinson Sword are a very balanced, consistent blade, good value and long-lasting plus - the main thing - a doddle to use !

I just ordered a 100 because I was down to single digits.
 
View attachment 1925963
Both of these manufacturers have a good reputation to uphold and are rightly respected here and the World over.

So I compared the two and found that Feathers are brilliant for 2-3 shaves max then they tug uncomfortably and have to go offski to the binski.
I have to use a consistent angle, smooth sweep and stable pressure otherwise they bite and can catch you out.

On some razors that clamp the blade well I can hear them start to bite and I reverse and go back with short strokes so I don`t get any nicks and weepers.

My very first shave with a Feather in my twenties - mid eighties time, I remember I got no nicks or redness just a little irritation that passed in a couple of hours - after that, I respected them more and approached them a different way to my run of the mill blades, being slightly slower and more cautious.

All my normal ones were just scrape and forget to me - I literally shave with my eyes shut in the bath listening to American Talk Radio podcasts - so no need for a mirror and I don`t need a brush - the dragon uses one on her legs etc. - Like the posh Yaqi tuxedo I surprised her with the other day.

I`ve learnt to use any soap over the years and being skint, I`ve had to improvise so I can use washing up liquid, shampoo, conditioner, washing liquid and powder, fabric conditioner (I wish I was kidding) and in the desert veg oil and booze - with an ancient cut-throat - so I`m not too fussy about soaps if good ones aren`t to hand; I can still manage a passable scrape.

In the heat, like in Cairo or Sharm in July where it`s 111 degrees at midnight my skin and nails grow faster and I need 2 shaves a day and 3 or 4 showers to assuage the dragon.
Alexandria is even worse for shaving and showering because of the humidity near the delta ; I prefer dry heat.

The Wilkinson Swords - especially my old ones are universally great with all my budget wonderful Chinese efforts and the pile of vintage cheapies I own.
Very smooth no rash or nicks and one blade does me for weeks - I`ve never counted accurately but defo more than ten.

I`ve got very resilient skin - never had spots as a kid and can survive hot sun abroad with no moisturiser and using just salad dressing - olive oil and vinegar as suncream - a la locals - I don`t burn I just go straight to brown thankfully.

So, to sum up I can use both brands but prefer the Wilki`s for shave and forget at any speed - with the Feathers I have to slow right down and be much more deliberate and accurate - like with an antique cut-throat - can`t remember the brands - it didn`t matter to me then - before I landed here.

Erm got 100 Wilkinsons coming early next week for £14 with 24hr courier dispatch - job`s a good `un.

I don`t care if they`re Chinese or Indian but prefer German going on past recollection of longevity and smoothness.

Oh brilliant, just read on the site that they`re German - yippee !

I agree. I enjoy the German Wilkies. I find them to feel very similar to my primary blade, the Bic CP. Sharp and smooth. That said, like you, I was fortunate enough to discover DE razors in my 20's as well, some 30 years ago, and that was the first and only time I used Feather as I found them to be harsh and abrasive. Fast forward to today, with all those years of experience under my belt now, I used a Feather again for the first time since then. All I can say is wow! I wish I had revisited this blade much sooner. I found the shave to be close and smooth. It'll be interesting to see how long they last me with my coarse facial hair.

As of now my top blades, in no particular order, are Bic CP, German Wilkinson's, Feathers, and Personna CC's.
 
Last edited:
WILKINSON SWORD AND DERBY RAZOR BLADES.jpg

I totally agree Dimitri about the Feathers but compared to a Belgium coticule honemeister honed 19th Century German carbon straight - it`s mild IMHO.

I love early pre WWII uncoated vintage carbon DE blades - now they are wicked sharp !

I must like carbon blades `cos I have used over a 100 in a year - they don`t last long - one or two scrapes but I love them just the same; I love carbon kitchen knives and scissors and hedge shears too - I was old old-fashioned when I was a teenager Dimitri.
 
Last edited:
Feather is a unique blade and nothing else is quite like it (Excellent blade!). The German Wilkinson isn't as sharp as a feather (nothing is) but is sharp enough and will last me for 10+ shaves without losing much of that sharpness. Very smooth too.


Feather is a Japanese made in Japan Product. Having years of dealing with the Japanese who were with Canon USA - Canon Professional Services, and involved in early EOS Project 35 mm Professional Camera.

The Japanese as a rule take nothing for granted, go crazy to get the smallest detail of a new product, until they get it right.

This is maybe what is unique about what I call the pricy Feather Blades, they are unique even thought they look like most DE Blades. Thing is about Feather blades they are consistently sharp, never had a bad one, never a dull one. Yes they are pricy, but worth the money, if you like, or need an extra sharp Blade.
 
Feather is a Japanese made in Japan Product. Having years of dealing with the Japanese who were with Canon USA - Canon Professional Services, and involved in early EOS Project 35 mm Professional Camera.

The Japanese as a rule take nothing for granted, go crazy to get the smallest detail of a new product, until they get it right.

This is maybe what is unique about what I call the pricy Feather Blades, they are unique even thought they look like most DE Blades. Thing is about Feather blades they are consistently sharp, never had a bad one, never a dull one. Yes they are pricy, but worth the money, if you like, or need an extra sharp Blade.
They look different from everything else under a microscope. They are ground with the best abrasives, so the scratches are very consistent in size. I suspect they use expensive synthetic abrasives.
 
Feathers are ground in such a way to give them a higher degree of sharpness than others, but they do not last as long. This isn't really a flaw, it's a deliberate trade-off. You could say Feathers are in their own category. Check out some of the microscope photos in the blade sharpness test thread posted by @helicopter. Certain razors provide much better results than others with Feather blades. Often these are mild shavers with good edge support such as Gillette Tech, for instance (but there are exceptions).

The Gillette Wilkinson Sword blades are entirely different than the German ones. The Indian blades are made for barbers and are moderately sharp and comfy though they don't last very many shaves. Good thing they are quite cheap.

You have pegged the German Wilkinson Sword as a great all-rounder that is fairly sharp and lasts a bit longer than average.
 
They look different from everything else under a microscope. They are ground with the best abrasives, so the scratches are very consistent in size. I suspect they use expensive synthetic abrasives.

I am not so OCD I look at Razor Blade under magnification device, but I am sure your observations are on the mark. When the Japanese decide to build something, they do it right.

Cousin worked for one of the Japanese Care Companies in US Headquarters, he said their R & D Department was alway play on new models 10 years out. That is forward think at it best, long term planning on steroids
 
The vintage Wilkinson Blades from the 70`s called Light Brigades wiped the floor with feathers IMHO - ten blades lasted me over a year !

I used vintage Carbon Feathers - i liked them a lot too.
 
For me, the German Wilkie would be the Porsche... consistent, dependable and quite sharp after a short break-in.

The Feather would be a Tesla Plaid, except one equipped with a non rechargeable battery. Super fast but after 300 miles, goes kaputt.

So yeah, apples and oranges.
 
When I started shaving in the 1960s (UK), I can only remember two brands of blade, Gillette and Wilkinson; at least that’s all the local chemist sold.
I started off with Gillette 7 O’clock and then changed to Wilkinson.
I can’t remember noticing any difference when Wilkinsons changed from English to German, and I’d say that Feathers are better than either of them.
 
When I started shaving in the 1960s (UK), I can only remember two brands of blade, Gillette and Wilkinson; at least that’s all the local chemist sold.
I started off with Gillette 7 O’clock and then changed to Wilkinson.
I can’t remember noticing any difference when Wilkinsons changed from English to German, and I’d say that Feathers are better than either of them.
I totally agree

Ankerwycke but you can`t get ten+ shaves out of a Feather - no way Jose.​

 
I`m used to using antique carbon straights with no water in a war-zone so DE`s are a walk in the park, just adaptation and practice isn`t it ?

You can improvise with booze and oil and stropping on a belt with toothpaste - easy !
How did the cowboys in the Wild west shave ? They managed just fine !
 
Top Bottom