Hannah's Dad
I Can See Better Than Bigfoot.
Captain’s Choice is stellar.
Who makes a good bay rum?
- Thread starter pokey074
- Start date
Captain's Choice is my favorite bay rum.
Col. Conk's bay rum smells amazing, too
Col. Conk's bay rum smells amazing, too
I have been enjoying Taylor of Old Bond Street's bay rum.
A very nice balanced scent.
A very nice balanced scent.
I got a bottle of the new Gables Bay Rum with menthol. I love the stuff. The scent lasts for about 4 hrs. Much longer than regular Gables (which I really like as well) It also does not seem to be quite as clove heavy as the regular. At anyrate, it is well worth the price, which is not high at all.
I detect no cat pee note in Clubman's Bay Rum. If you like longevity, it's one of the best. It's also one of the most likely to irritate and also has alot of alcohol, however. It's more of a cologne than an aftershave, honestly.
The best Bay Rum aftershave that I've found so far:
Authentic ingredients, classic recipe = great bay rum.
Authentic ingredients, classic recipe = great bay rum.
Never tried it, but the packaging alone is very nice!
DM me and I'll send you a few varieties. No charge.
New acquisition:
love the bay rum, need to decide which one to spring for. so many choices.
It's really hard to choose. Captains Choice is the absolute closest to (in my opinion) the best: vintage Avon.
The Captain is running a contest! His annual Christmas PIF of ANYTHING in his catalog. Or is it catalogue to those weirdos (or is it weirdoes?) in Canuck Land?! Anyway, I challenge you to find a better one.
But enter his contest, because we want to hear your story of giving!
Ron R
I survived a lathey foreman
SE SOTD, Wed, Dec 09th 2020
Used some great inexpensive Bayrum products today. If you like a little clove in your Bay rum with some sandalwood you will definitely like the Ogallala . I like the Colonel Conk & Ogallala bay rum soaps, they are not overpowering but they are just that masculine scent most would enjoy IMO and are better for you skin with excellent post shaves.
Have some great shaves! Stay & think safe in these times!
Used some great inexpensive Bayrum products today. If you like a little clove in your Bay rum with some sandalwood you will definitely like the Ogallala . I like the Colonel Conk & Ogallala bay rum soaps, they are not overpowering but they are just that masculine scent most would enjoy IMO and are better for you skin with excellent post shaves.
Have some great shaves! Stay & think safe in these times!
Last edited:
I highly, HIGHLY recommend PAA atomic age bay rum. its the most 'masculine' AS scent i've ever experienced and i've tried quite a few.
fantastic.
fantastic.
I like them...but I find that their scents change dramatically about 30 minutes after application. Love to smell them in the bottle though. I have several PAA soaps. Good stuff!
I like Grand Bay bay rum. Mild alcohol burn, smells great, but fleeting. By way of comparison, I've tried Captain's Choice (too strong, too much burn), Ogallala (too oily, not "bay rum" enough), and St. Johns (a close second, with a little more burn).
Ive not tried it yet to but I’ve read good reviews of razorocks
My favorite is Rooster’s Nest Bourbon Bay Rum. I like St John and Grand Bay Rum too, but Rooster’s Nest is tops for me.
$26??? Wow, I'll keep making my own.
Hmm, I had not heard this. I was turned off by a poor razor purchase. Trying to be open-minded, but having difficulty when I feel a bit used.
