I assume you apply the witch hazel and the Osage rub after you shower.
Yes. Dry shave, shower, dry off, mentholated witch hazel as my aftershave every time, finish getting dressed, and I'm done. I liberally apply the osage rub on date nights as it has a light scent but doesn't aggravate my wife's scent sensitive nose, I also keep a small spray bottle of it in my car and give a spritz or two throughout the day. Besides that the mentholated witch hazel is technically my only aftershave.