What's your favorite bay rum aftershave

[modern man]

Masters Bay Rum is the better aftershave but St Johns smells a little better.

 

[Duckster]

anybody tried royall bay rhum?

Royall Bay Rhum was way too clovie for me.

I guess someone should jump in and say Ogallala. I like the sweetness and the lack of cloviness (sic).

The Dominica Bay Rum (Lime version) is excellent (the brown glass bottle with the cork stopper and green label). No clove scent, just bay rum and lime. Fantastic.

I'll have to give Ogallala and Dominica bay rums a try.

 

[MrFusion]

1. Pinaud
2. Ogallala Bay Rum
3. CO Bigelow
4. Lustray Bay Rum (no cloves smells great but doesn't last)

I need to try Royall and Dominica (with and without lime) and I will pick up some Masters the next time I see it.

 

[sehrgut]

Royall Bay Rhum was way too clovie for me.

Odd . . . Maybe I'm too used to the Pinaud and Ogallala, because I detect very little in the way of spice notes in the Royall. It's much more a true bay rum to my nose.

 

[Kouros]

Ogallala bay rum was extremely disappointing. It smells like Vicks Vapo Rub to me.

 

[Grizzled Veteran]

Humco, followed by Saint Charles Shave's Bay Rum with a Twist, followed by Pinaud.

 

[rail road detective]

Have always used St. John's - plan on trying Pusser's - friend reccomends it.

 

[peterluu]

For pure Bay Rum with nothing else added: Dominica
For some added to the scent: Royall Bay Rhum
When I have the time : Homemade from Pure Essential Oil distilled from the Pimenta racemosa leaf.

 

[Bristlingbeardofodin]

Pinaud.