Top 3 (Your all star team)

[coonskinner]

Stirling

Tabac

MWF

 

[mfgorilla]

1. Body Shop Maca Root

2. AOS unscented

3. CO Bigelow

 

[DanOK]

Three creams I will never be without are:

T&H Trafalgar
Castle Forbes Lavendar
Geo F Trumper Violet

 

[wijkowski]

Penhaligon's Edymion/BB
Proraso Red
ADP

Men-U is climbing on my list, Really into this one right now (Christmas Gift). I was not expecting much from it, but it is fantastic. I like the locking pump packaging as well.

Ron

 

[Rasage_Perfecto]

Irish Moos
Cade
Proraso Green

 

[Handy]

Castle Forbes Lime
Penhaligon's Bleheim Bouquet
Santa Maria Novella

 

[FloydianDM]

For creams:

TOBS Avocado
Speick
Palmolive Classic

 

[Coffeesnob]

currently for creams:

XPEC original shaving cream
Castle Forbes lime/lavender
Proraso green

 

[allin8183]

1. Tabac, 2. TOBS Sandalwood and 3. William's Mug (one of these things is not like the other...)

 

[saltypaws]

In no particular order:

T&H 1805
GFT Violet
Bluebeard's Revenge

 

[Lakebound]

Proraso Blue
Cella
TOBS Mr. Taylor

Frank

 

[vsingh]

Godrej
TOBS Sandlewood
Proraso

 

[xraygun]

I Coliniali Rhubarb
Cyril R Salter French Vetiver
Veleiro

Amusing how different our tastes are. Not one of mine has been mentioned. I must be a weirdo.

 

[Joeynets]

Proraso Green
Musgo Real Oak Moss
ToOBS Jermyn Street

 

[jddssc121]

CF Lime
Trumper violet
3rd place tie between TGR Black Ice and nancyboy Signature

 

[Kyrlos]

TOBS Rose
Speick
Edwin Jagger Menthol

 

[tomharr51]

TOBS Sandalwood
Proraso Green
QCS Vodstok

 

[Jinx18]

Best Menthol/Cooling/Tingly/Summertime
Proraso Green

Best Clean Smelling
Proraso Blue
TOBS St. James

Best Warm/Wintertime
TOBS Sandalwood
Proraso Red

Best "Healthy"/Clean Feeling
TOBS Avocado
Edwin Jagger Aloe Vera

 

[babybottomsmooth]

Penhaligon's BB

LEA Professional

Proraso

 

[adelphos1]

My top three are

Maria Santa Novella
Castle Forbes
La Toja

If forced, I would choose the lavender in the Castle Forbes over the other scents but I like all three. Penhaligon's and Musgo Real put up a fight for the number three slot.