So I tried Mama Bear's Aged Spice. It's not bad. It lather quite easily, but is a bit thin. The scent does not compare to vintage Old Spice soap. Can anyone suggest a soap that might be closer the scent of the original??
Mystic Waters makes an Old Spice scented soap called Windjammer. I've never had Old Spice soap so I can't give a comparison. I can vouch for the quality of MW soaps though.