I ordered the Bay Rum tin and a tin of Barbershop this weekend and they both arrived today. I did a test lather to try to get some of the funk off of the Vie-Long Butterscotch Beehive Silvertip which arrived today from Phil at Bullgoose. These soaps are a bit thirsty, as others have mentioned, but the lather was thick and super slick. I can not wait to shave with these. The scents are AMAZING.