What's new

Lotta Bay Rhum talk lately.

...so when I saw a Turtle Bay display in Tommy Bahama with the wife yesterday, I decided to amble over and take a whiff. This immediately turned off the 60-something year old sales lady, who had been chatting me up and placing her hands all over her soft and ample and exposed decolletage thanks to a wench like blouse (sorry about the visual and I hope I don't get banned!) as I walked from display to display and made my way to the Bay Rum. "You don't want that," she said. "It is very spicy and it isn't Tommy Bahama. It is Turtle Bay." She tried to lure me away from the Turtle Bay fragrances and shaving cream tester, over to the Tommy Bahama fragrance, "which is fresh and light, like you just took a shower! [bats eyes again]" I resisted and took a whiff of the cream and I was back in the islands until she said, "Why do you want to smell like the kitchen?" She had a couple more derogatory comments before I left the shop, but I still left smelling like an Easter ham!

Her associate tried hard to downplay the strength of the scent, remembering that she was in retail sales. "You want to smell it a couple hours after it has been applied."

My wife and I enjoyed the visit, but walked out empty handed. Bay Rhum is pretty polarizing, even with the older crowd, eh?
 
Last edited:
While at work (Ambulance man) I often get calls to elderly Caribean men who use the Bay, or Tabac. I've notice most use the 'Benjamins' brand here in blighty. So I grabbed a menthol and a reglar and they're in the den. They freshen me up after work when I get home. Both burn off prety quick and are light in the fragrance dept but I and SWMBO like them.
 
I'm the odd man out. I have received samples of Bay Rum, and all I get is a clove like - plastic- smell. It doesn't smell good to me at all.
 
Turtle Bay is a neghborhood in Manahattan, so I would be suspect of how much they know about rum, but I too and on the face rum discovery tour.
 
Got the $1 sample from Ogallala and I also bought a bar of soap/shampoo. John included 3 bottles of different aftershaves with the package as an extra! I really like them, I feel like I could develop a Bay Rum problem now.
 
I guess I'm inda confused FL Shaver... did you like the Turtle Bay Rum or not?
I sprayed a bit on my L forearm and took a whiff. It smelled like Bay Rhum. I did not get as far as the price, but figured Superior 70 was at least as good and probably much cheaper. The visceral reaction of the sales lady is what struck me most about trying the Turtle Bay version of the old classic scent.
 
My wife absolutely loves the Captain's Choice Bay Rum and so do I. It's a great stuff that has an amazing moisturizing qualities, for a splash.
 
My wife absolutely loves the Captain's Choice Bay Rum and so do I. It's a great stuff that has an amazing moisturizing qualities, for a splash.

Krampert's is a notch above in moisturizing, IMO. BUT I prefer the Captain's scent a little more. Its a toss up, so I will use both!
 
Just don't use the VIBR straight if you shaved. :bayrum2: to the 10000 power. Its alcohol burn is insane followed by the typical bay rum burn. I didn;t realize it was not supposed to be like that until i tried the Ogallala.
 
I finally tried gilbert henry. I can live with this one. It's got a orange sweetness to it that works.
 
Top Bottom