I think the OP meant facial moisturiser or balm, not shave cream
I have tried all 3 and Jack Black wins hands down. L'Occitane makes good stuff and I use their products but prefer JB for a facial moisturizer. Keihl's oil free made my face super shiny by the end of the day. Also check out JB's Protein Booster Skin Serum. I use it after I shave (every other day) and all other days use JB's Double Duty (w/ SPF). Even my wife has converted and now uses Jack Black. Feel free to PM me if you have specific questions or want more details. edit: I'm replying to an almost 2 month old original post. Oh well, maybe someone will find this useful.
No doubt someone will find this useful.
I'm about to receive Nancy Boy Facial Moisturizer to see how that works out. Their Body Moisturizer is pretty nice with facial grade ingredients, but with my skin, I want to see if the step up for specially designed stuff is worth it. Knowing their products, most likely. I haven't tried the JB balm, but the moisturizer/sunscreen is some of the best, in terms of sunscreen. Never tried a Kiehls product, and L'Occitane... hear it's pretty nice, but man, its expensive! Not that any of the others I've mentioned are cheap...