I'm a newb, so I only have four (at this time). Old Spice (classic scent), Stetson, Pinaud clubman and Aqua Velva. The winner was the Clubman, but only by a nose over the Stetson. Personally, I'm more of a Old Spice guy, probably cause it reminds me of my Grandfather. Still, it was pretty cool watching my four year old sniffing all the bottles. Gotta add some more so she has more options.