Definitely not those, they are great in their own right but nothing like Clubman. The only one I know of that is actually made using Clubman AS to ensure the same scent is CBL Premium Soaps (I used to have some awhile back but not sure of the current soap status).I always forget about Clubman Friday. Anyway, an off-topic question, what soap would match Clubman Original ? RazoRock American Barber? Fine American Blend maybe? Any other choices?