DR Harris Pink a/s milk scent help

[SirWhiskers]

What does the rose milk smell like?

Does the Arlington milk smell anything like the Arlington shaving cream in a jar?

I'm torn between the Arlington milk and the rose milk.

In terms of feel and performance I assume both are the same formula only different scents?

 

[Paris]

Just used the pink label milk today - to me the scent is very ordinary - reminds me of cold cream - not at all masculine.
I would go for the Arlington. I assume they both are basically the same with different scents.

 

[Tom Ford]

The Pink ASM smells like rose. While the scent isn't masculine IMO it doesn't last long (30 mins), the milk itself is brilliant.

Having the Arlington SC and soap, I much prefer it's scent to the rose.

If it were me, I'd go the Arlington

 

[SirWhiskers]

Thanks. Rose is not my favorite scent. I hope the Arlington milk smells close to the cream.

 

[HoratioCaine]

Hmm...I wonder if there might be a better term than referring to it as "Pink a/s milk," as it is easy to confuse with the Pink Aftershave, which is a splash. Based on the thread title, I thought the OP had confused the two products. Now I get it, but the term still has potential to confuse, especially if it caught on and everybody started using it. Perhaps "standard" or "rose" Harris Milk might be better.

 

[SirWhiskers]

Sorry, I didn't know what to call it and I saw he splash referred to as the pink so I figured it carried over to the asb. I'll change the thread title if I can.

 

[SirWhiskers]

I ended up buying a bottle of Arlington milk and I really, really like it. It has become my new standard to judge other milks and balms on. The scent I don't find that great but the milk makes my skin very very happy like nothing I've tried before and I've tried lots of things.