Wow, lots of people voting for a miata. I never fully understood why some call them 'girly'?
Wow, lots of people voting for a miata. I never fully understood why some call them 'girly'?
In the under $10k category for a rag top, I think the Miata will be hard to beat. I would not trust a 911 (or any Porsche) that could be had for less than $10k -- I'm not sure why it keeps getting mentioned. Porsches are fantastic sports cars, but way more money than you said you want to spend, even second hand.
tell that to "Bullet" in australia.Because women love them, love driving them, and love how they look better in one. Yep, a miata is basically an upscale pair of shoes to a woman. One nice thing about this is that girls will be more impressed by your miata than your corvette. Bad thing about this is that if you marry her the miata will become "her car" and you'll be driving her tercel.
tell that to "Bullet" in australia.
A few years ago they were shoving turbo 13B rotaries, 20B turbo rotaries and supercharged lexus V8s into miatas. I think they didn't get the memo that a miata is an all show, no go, womens accessory.
How about that Honda S2000? I do not even know if they still make it, but ultra high reving engine.
EDIT: I missed the reference below to the S2000 at first. Should be a fun reliable car. No idea what they cost used. They did make them at least through '09.
I just sold my '02 a couple of years ago for 11K (it had ~80K miles). It was a fantastically fun car with a 9K redline. They dropped the redline to 8000 for the 2004 and newer models FWIW. I loved this car and might look for one in the future.
I certainly do recommend one and think you can find one for ~10K.
Just curious. How was reliability? I assume very good. Or were there there any issues with a motor that revs that high/is capable or reving that high? Even 8k is a lot of rpms!
I used to have an RX7, too. I am disappointed that that engine has continued to be as inefficient as it is. Too low a gas mileage for the power output, even though it is also low wieght, if I recall, but very, very reliable these days--motor and car overall, at least the '84 or so GSL-SE I had. As I recall, the rotory engine revs pretty high, too. Always seemed like a good combination with a CV transmission to me, for some reason, but it has never happened!
Forget the 911...you want a 951. Especially at the <10k price point. Better driving dynamics than a 911, infinitely tunable and a whole lot cheaper. I can't think of a better driver's car that can be had for $10k...maybe an E30 M3, but it will be hard to find a good one, and they're finicky...not to mention not as fast and a lot more expensive to tune.
You forgot to mention the part about how much uglier the 951 is than a 911. YMMV, of course...
YMMV indeed...Lets face it...the iconic 356/911 shape is not exactly well balanced or elegant. It was an attempt to make the VW bug sleek and sporty. The 356 pulled it off because they kept it simple and clean...and with the exception of the obnoxiously tall cockpit, the lines really were kind of sleek and elegant (the 356 roadster was much more beautiful than the coupe...who would argue with that?). But where the 356 was graceful and clean, the early 911's were just untidy...blame the bumpers more than anything. The targas were the worst...really dreadful looking cars IMO.
The 930 was a lot better...the whale tail balanced out the ludicrous bumpers to a certain extent, but it was still far from elegant.
The n/a 944's (excluding the later S2 models that had the turbo bumpers) suffered from the same affliction (ridiculous bumpers). The turbo fixed that, and the car became quite beautiful. It was perfectly balanced aesthetically...it had graceful, elegant lines that hadn't been available from Porsche since the 356 Roadster, and nothing to detract from that simple beauty.
As long as you don't get caught up in that "if the engine is up front its not a real porsche" nonsense, I can't see why anyone would want a $10k 911 rather than a $10k 951. The 951 is the better car in every way. But then, as you said, YMMV.