That's a nice list you have. Of the ones I've tried off your list, here are my thoughts:
Osage Rub is highly mentholated & has a strong medicine odor. But it sure cools you off!
Lucky Tiger is very nice, great face feel, scent is light & doesn't last long at all.
Old Spice is strong going on, but not a great scent anymore.
Pinaud Clubman is remarkable! Scent is classic, powdery, & reminds me of days gone by. Scent lingers for hours & can be recharged by appliying a dab of water to your face. Wonderful AS. I add 5 - 6 drops of glycerin to a bottle & it provides good face feel also. All around great aftershave.
But of course, YMMV. (This is a disclaimer that could be put at the end of every shave related review.)
Osage Rub is highly mentholated & has a strong medicine odor. But it sure cools you off!
Lucky Tiger is very nice, great face feel, scent is light & doesn't last long at all.
Old Spice is strong going on, but not a great scent anymore.
Pinaud Clubman is remarkable! Scent is classic, powdery, & reminds me of days gone by. Scent lingers for hours & can be recharged by appliying a dab of water to your face. Wonderful AS. I add 5 - 6 drops of glycerin to a bottle & it provides good face feel also. All around great aftershave.
But of course, YMMV. (This is a disclaimer that could be put at the end of every shave related review.)