Both the shave cream and aftershave are still sold where I am.
Shave cream - IMHO stay away from it. No cushion, glide or protection. If you really want to try a good brushless cream that doesn't lather try any of the ones made by Alba.
Aftershave - I had a similar experience; it felt 'heavy' to me but I didn't get stickiness. May have some moisturizing ability but it has no soothing/healing properties (which you really need after trying the shave cream).
Burts Bees Bay Rum Cologne, if you can find it, is one of the most potent bay rum cologne's I have ever come across. 1 spray to the chest will introduce you to the room 5 minutes before you arrive - no joke! I love it but I spray it on at least 2 hours before I leave the house.