I sometimes wonder if my premium soaps are really 10-20+ times better.
They're not.
It's a good soap at an excellent price point. I find the scent to be ok and the slickness and cushion to be above average but it's a drying soap so might turn off some. It's not top shelf but it's great for its price point and competes with some mid range soaps very well.
I think s good comparison is that Arko is like named brand canned vegetables. Not as good as frozen. Not as good as fresh. But pretty darned good for everyday for the most part.
When I first got arko,it smelled like laundry detergent. Now it smells lemony. I really have no idea where people got the urinal puck smell from. Arko smells good enough for me that I have to smell it every time I walk past the bathroom.
Tabac and MWF top it slightly because of slickness/post shave feel, but I have a couple expensive soaps that don't. I actually love the scent, as well.