Tabac is one of my favorites. It lathered like a champ for me, and I (despite being in my 30s) actually like the scent.
Once I got a water softener I felt like the lather was exploding right off the puck. MWF lathered just a touch better for me pre water softener, but after having my water softened they appear equal (perhaps an edge to the Tabac) and I prefer the scent. The Tabac AS pairs well with it too (unsurprisingly).
The lather is great when just building it with a wet brush. I don't even need to wet or bloom the puck. If you bowl lather after reaching a peak on the brush when building the lather, and add about 2 more drops of water, the lather really explodes.
Would you agree that the Tabac aftershave lasts on the skin for about 2 hours? I find that the cologne projects for about 2 hours
and stays on the skin for about 5 hours.