I've revived interest in .40 S&W. Wish there were more varied loadings; it's one I don't reload.
Who prefers it? In what, and why?
AA
Who prefers it? In what, and why?
AA
.40: Short & Weak, or just right?
- Thread starter Ad Astra
- Start date
I prefer it when on duty. Bigger like the .45, but faster like the 9mm. Best of both worlds. Something comforting about 165 grain Gold Dot moving at 1200 feet per second.
Yes, a 9mm recoils less and is "more" controllable then the .40. But a .22 is "more" controllable than the 9mm.And the .40 is "more" controllable then a .44 Magnum, so on and so on. Glock 23 on duty, Glock 19 or 43X off duty.
I used to own a SA XD40, but sold it and am now a G19/G43 guy.
Great question, one that I have myself. I keep going back and forth between wanting a .40 and a .45 as a regular carry firearm in the future. Okie's endorsement puts the .40 higher on my list. Unfortunately, one can't rent a firearm in NY to try before you buy. However, since I just purchased a new car for my wife, another firearm is on hold for a little longer anyhow.
Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
simon1
Self Ignored by Vista
I prefer it when on duty. Bigger like the .45, but faster like the 9mm. Best of both worlds. Something comforting about 165 grain Gold Dot moving at 1200 feet per second.
And the .40 is "more" controllable then a .44 Magnum, so on and so on. Glock 23 on duty, Glock 19 or 43X off duty.
^^^What he said. A lot of police departments went to it. Then, after "complaints" from "some" people they went back to the 9 mm for less recoil. I think Jordan, Keith, Skelton, and a few others recommended a .40 or .41 caliber bullet moving at about 900-1,000 fps. I've shot both the Glock 17 and have a Glock 22 and I can't tell much difference in the recoil level.
Also, the old .38-40 was very popular in the Old West days. Even with the black powder loads it had the same ballistics as the .40 S&W. The bullet diameter is actually .40, not .38 as it's a heeled bullet, and with black powder loads it pushed a 180 gr. bullet at about 900 fps.
I usually carry a 14 oz. Colt Cobra .38 Special as it is so easy to carry. But I carry 158 gr. soft LSW HP +P in it. Let me tell you...the recoil of that is much worse than a full size .40 S&W.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #6
I prefer it when on duty. Bigger like the .45, but faster like the 9mm. Best of both worlds. Something comforting about 165 grain Gold Dot moving at 1200 feet per second.
And the .40 is "more" controllable then a .44 Magnum, so on and so on. Glock 23 on duty, Glock 19 or 43X off duty.
What I would call a qualified endorsement!
Thanks.
AA
- Thread starter
- #7
- Thread starter
- #8
Price of ammo counts for something, too. Falls neatly in-between 9mm and .45, as with its power, cap, etc. too.
AA
AA
Much improved shooting personality.
The .40 S&W is a very capable cartridge. No problems with it as far as I'm concerned. I have two pistols in that caliber but rarely shoot them much anymore. A Glock 27 and a SIG P229. I have been toying with sending the SIG in to get the SRT upgrade and begin shooting the .40 S&W again.
40 like 10 and 357sig are great examples of sell the sizzle.
With modern defensive bullets, the difference between calibers has become less a factor in deciding effectiveness. I shoot mostly 9 mm pistols these days, not because I believe it is a superior choice in performance, but you can have more bullets in the gun with a 9mm than you can a .40 or .45., all other things being equal. I still love the other calibers. I'll always have the guns.
Care to elaborate? I would assume that it could be changed back to the standard DA/SA pull if I didn't like it.
Sure.
Indeed the return to an OEM trigger set up is simple and cost free; just a parts swap.
I found the SRT can work almost too well, facilitating and setting off a second shot really quickly. Almost like a bump stock. There is a more than slight learning curve.
Indeed the return to an OEM trigger set up is simple and cost free; just a parts swap.
I found the SRT can work almost too well, facilitating and setting off a second shot really quickly. Almost like a bump stock. There is a more than slight learning curve.
You should start reloading for it. It’s all I carry. I have 2. One is my edc and the other is under the bedside table and goes with me on hunting trips. I load 180 gr hard cast for the range and use 180 gr JHP for my edc ammo. I feel like it’s the perfect middle ground between 9 and 45. Ammo is readily available and fairly low cost. I have nothing against either of the others. I just prefer the 40.
AoM; B.O.S.S.;Knight of the Veg Table;MFR2019
AoM; B.O.S.S.;Knight of the Veg Table;MFR2019
Probably my favorite to shoot/re-load. Have it in a Sig P229 and a Ruger PC-40
When your life is on the line the last thing you need is a Jam Special & thats why the Leo's in my area carry it. I prefer a 10 guage for home defense myself.
This is true, but not by much in some guns. My Glock 19 carries 15+1 9mm and my Glock 23 carries 13+1 in .40.
simon1
Self Ignored by Vista
You can always get an extended magazine. A D.A.s investigator was walking around the courtroom one time with one of these in his Glock, in a shoulder holster, and his jacket off...during a trial.
https://www.brownells.com/magazines...l-17-34-9mm-33-round-magazines-prod71433.aspx
Talk about being able to spray and pray.
