Easily my most complimented, however I am about to get Hermes d'orange Verte I expect that will not do badly.
Your Top 3 Most Complimented Colognes
- Thread starter rockero
- Start date
Easily my most complimented, however I am about to get Hermes d'orange Verte I expect that will not do badly.
Lately, it's been Prada Luna Rossa. A great cold weather scent.
i often wear rather expensive, niche fragrances, but am as likely to have my wife compliment Cool Wave as anything else in my cupboard. The ones most likely to get compliments outside of the house are;
- Montale Patchouli Leaves
- Creed Aventus
- Creed Windsor
1) Bleu De Chanel
2) VS Very Sexy for men #1
3) D&G Light Blue
2) VS Very Sexy for men #1
3) D&G Light Blue
Pen's English Fern
Pen's Sartorial
Domenico Caraceni 1913 (in VERY small doses - what a powerful edt this one is!)
Pen's Sartorial
Domenico Caraceni 1913 (in VERY small doses - what a powerful edt this one is!)
This is highly complimented on me as well. Interesting that you like it as a cold weather scent. I have always viewed it as more of a spring/summer scent. I have worn it in the winter and I will say that it is definitely strong enough to cut through the cold air. I just prefer scents that have tobacco, incense, leather, amber, woody notes, etc for cold weather. As they say different strokes for different folks!
Memoirs of a Trespasser seems to go over very well.
For me, the most complimented colognes I own are Nautica Voyage. Next is Tommy by Tommy Hilfiger, and Curve in the original golden tin. Depending on the time of year it is, the last two switch places. Nevertheless, Nautica Voyage is always complimented. 
Warmer months:
1.) Chanel Platinum Egoiste
2.) Bleu De Chanel
3.) Creed Aventus
Colder months:
1.) Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit de l`Homme
2.) Dior Homme Intense
3.) Yves Saint Laurent L`Homme
1.) Chanel Platinum Egoiste
2.) Bleu De Chanel
3.) Creed Aventus
Colder months:
1.) Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit de l`Homme
2.) Dior Homme Intense
3.) Yves Saint Laurent L`Homme
Apparently Old Spice is great on me but I seldom touch it anymore.
Having recently 'discovered' Stetson, I've had no negativity from it.
Aqua Velva Musk, has LONG been something people say 'suits me'.
Having recently 'discovered' Stetson, I've had no negativity from it.
Aqua Velva Musk, has LONG been something people say 'suits me'.
I had initially thought of it as a warm weather scent, too, but there is something about it's crispness that just seems to "work" in colder temps.
1. Creed Aventus by a mile
2. Armani Code
3. Oscar de Larenta Por Lui, from the 80's
2. Armani Code
3. Oscar de Larenta Por Lui, from the 80's
- Thread starter
- #54
Lots of good feedback. I need to try many new colognes listed here.
- Thread starter
- #55
I also like the Beckham signature scent. I haven't smelled the other scents.
Making a few updates since the weather has changed and getting cooler:
- Dior Homme Intense - Although I do not wear it often as I much prefer it for formal/suit/sports coats events, it remains the runaway winner for complements
- Terre d'Hermes EdP
- Dolce & Gabbana The One
Dolce and Gabbana The One. If it's good enough for Matthew McConaughy . . 
Aramis Original
Terre d Hermes
Bleu de Chanel
Terre d Hermes
Bleu de Chanel
Last edited:
My 3 favorites are:
1) Roma by Laura Biagiotti
2) Very Valentino
3) Gucci Guilty and 1 Million by Paco Rabanne (tied for 3rd)
The one my lady really likes on me the most, but I'm not as crazy about is Fahrenheit by Dior.
1) Roma by Laura Biagiotti
2) Very Valentino
3) Gucci Guilty and 1 Million by Paco Rabanne (tied for 3rd)
The one my lady really likes on me the most, but I'm not as crazy about is Fahrenheit by Dior.
