What's new

You left a hole in my Hart (razor)

No, it's not THAT bad, but the whole episode was horrifying to me. Basically I damaged my Hart razor through ignorance and/or neglect. Some of the details are a bit intriguing to me and maybe to you. I try to highlight what I think are the important details. Please provide your input.

I started out as a newbie with the Hart and love(d) it. Used it, wiped it down and dried before putting it away in its little leather case. I would use it every 2-3 days and had no problems except for one water stain that appeared relatively early on.

About two weeks ago, my tube of Maas showed up and I went to work taking out that little stain. For good measure I worked took the scales off (little hex screw on the Hart) and cleaned/worked the whole blade. Put it back together, put it in its leather case and put it away, *in the drawer in the bathroom*.

I then did my next shave with my Bismark, and it went well. A bunch of new soaps arrived and I wanted to test them out and compare them without adding in the razor variable. Long story short, the Hart was untouched for two weeks.

Sunday, I went to the Hart and took it out. HORROR. Little whiskers of *stuff* were growing out of the metal on the sides AND the spine. I immediately grabbed a cloth and started rubbing (and cursing of course). I should have examined the growths more closely, but like a mother protecting her child I acted first and asked questions later.

I now have blemishes on my razor. They are not deep, in fact I don't even think I can feel them at all. The growths occurred *only* above the portion of the blade that was exposed above the scales (but it was in its leather sheath??). There is a distinct line along the blade that demarcates where the scales lay along the blade when it is closed.

Now I am not a metalsmith, but I do have a materials background and have a basic understanding of metal. These growths did not look liek normal rust to me. They did not grow parallel to the surface, but grew out of it. It looked like the Hart had a few days beard (an ironic insult to a razor!). The growths almost looked like short zinc whiskers, but I don't think O-1 steel (Hart steel) has any Zinc.

My colleague who *IS* a metalurgist wonders whether the razor was differentially hardened and that the relatively coarser grain structure along the upper sides and spine allowed for these growths at the grain boundaries.

Does anyone have any ideas? I definitely didn't treat the lower part of the razor any different than the upper.

Any suggestions on how to proceed to take out these unsightly blemishes? They don't seem to be pits, and are now shiny. It's like I have a macroscopic view of the microstructure.
 
Pictures would certainly help, of what it looks now. It does sound strange, but without pictures I wonder if it was just the fuzz from the inside of the leather pouch that attached itself to the exposed metal; but you say the Maas doesn't take out the new blemishes? Maybe even with the fuzz removed, the stains underneath are giving you another impression of what it was.

It would be a hard learned lesson, but it is normally not a good idea to store a freshly used razor back in the leather pouch, in a moist environment (bathroom), bad things are bound to happen.

Good luck and let us know what you find out.
 
Last edited:
If you had a metallurgist look at it and offer no insight, there's nothing I can say... Pictures could help..

As a general rule, I like to let steel breath in a dry environment... I don't keep steel in cases or leather for extended periods. Trapped moisture can be a villainous opponent!

The good news is, that a trip back to Hart could put everything right... So, not to worry!
 
Thanks for the feedback guys. I'm at work now, but I'll try to post pictures later.

You mentioned drying the razor before storing. Did you coat it with oil or any protectant?

Yes, I realize that this happened due to my neglect, I'm more interested in the the way the rust(?) formed. I've seen rusty things before, but never seen whiskers form normal to the surface.

Oh, to slightly rationalize my neglect. My tube of Maas said it would also protect the metal. But ... apparently not.
 
The main point of my question about use of oil was not to point out neglect. If you had used oil, and it was say a vegetable-based oil, my question was going to be whether the growth might have been feeding off the oil.
 
The main point of my question about use of oil was not to point out neglect. If you had used oil, and it was say a vegetable-based oil, my question was going to be whether the growth might have been feeding off the oil.

This whole thing reminds me of the episode in The Empire Strikes Back, where those flying nasties were trying to feed off the power cables of the Millenium Falcon!

EDIT:

And you should point out my neglect. Every member here should chide me for my carelessness. I should be forced to walk the gauntlet with my head held in shame as members beat me with their strops!
 
Last edited:
This whole thing reminds me of the episode in The Empire Strikes Back, where those flying nasties were trying to feed off the power cables of the Millenium Falcon!

I just hope the nasties feeding off metal stay East of Texas! If they venture here, we'll fight them off with chainsaws.
 
This seems like an odd occurance! I suppose i'll toss my vote in the hat for pics as well.

Perhaps they'll shed some light...
 
Okay, I'm going to to post some pictures.

To recap,

I do not have any pictures of the "growths" or rust. As soon as I saw them, I attacked them with a cloth and Maas.

The growths grew out of the surface of the metal. They weren't flakes of rust or small deposits that I've seen on 4340 and such. If I had to guestimate, I'd say they were a full millimeter or so above the surface.

I cannot feel the "pitting". If I close my eyes and feel the metal, I can't tell where the pitted surface starts and stops. It all feels smooth.
 
This whole thing reminds me of the episode in The Empire Strikes Back, where those flying nasties were trying to feed off the power cables of the Millenium Falcon!

EDIT:

And you should point out my neglect. Every member here should chide me for my carelessness. I should be forced to walk the gauntlet with my head held in shame as members beat me with their strops!

SHAME!

for SHAME!

Two weeks with a Fusion, and a can of goo for you!
 
Seconded!

They do look like the beginning of pits. One of our restoration guys should be able make the blade look much better.

I haven't paid much attention to regular pitting. Please zoom in on the images. Does pitting have the same structure as can be seen in my pictures?
 
Very difficult to tell from the pics, but it does look like the remnants of oxidation.
Leather can be tanned with many different chemicals... Some less friendly toward steel than others. Since all the oxidation appears above the area protected by the scales, that would be my guess.
I'm sure lots of folks could take care of it, but if it were mine, it would go back to Hart.. They know the specific techniques, machinery and grits to match it perfectly..

Just my $.02
 
Top Bottom