Which of the two deodorants should I choose? Malin+Goetz or Nancy Boy

[The MazinAzn]

Hello Guys,

I'm in a debate which natural deodorant I should get. I currently am using Malin+Goetz, and it works effectively, but I was seeing if Nancy boy's spray would work better. So would it be worth trying Nancy Boy or should I just stick to Malin Goetz?

 

[Redman667]

I am using the Nancy Boy spray deodorant right now, it good but not great. After a day of working I need to reapply before I go to the gym because I am not feeling completely fresh I have the signature scent and the smell is great but pretty strong. I am on the fence about reordering once its gone.

 

[Bubblehead]

If you want a deodorant that stings to high hell, get Nancy Boy. I have no experience with Malin + Goetz. Right now I'm using EO Cool Vetiver and it works as well as Nancy Boy, but it's main ingredient is water so while it's scent isn't as strong as Nancy Boy, it doesn't sting either.

I want to note that I shave my armpits 2-3 times a month, which although makes all deodorants a kajillion times more effective, it obviously contributed in some part to Nancy Boy's sting.

 

[Terp61]

I tried a Crystal stick months ago and I like it so much it's my go to now. No scent and a solid performer, without any staining and never feels "waxy".

 

[Jerry-built Hustler]

My go-round with Nancy Boy left me quite stinky, which is not a problem I have with my usual deodorant (Almay). YMMV, but NB was a no-go for me.