Which Castle Forbes after shave balm?

[rum]

OK, so I thought it would be fun to make this a poll. I love the Lime scent as I can pair that with any other EdT or EdP that I own (well, roughly) and I have owned it in the past. But the Lavender is marketed as suitable for sensitive skins, so it may be more soothing/gentle, although I've not tried it to see for myself.

I also tried the 1445 at one point and that was a whole good scent all on its own!

So, which would you go for and why? Please vote!

 

[mistercitizen]

I am going to go with lavender since I only have CF Lavender and have never tried Limes. I also have CF 1445 balm and edt, but I use the lavender balm more because it pairs nicely with many of the lavender soaps, creams, and splashes I use. I guess I'm sort of a lavender for the cold weather and limes for the warm weather kind of guy so maybe before summer I will have to pick up the CF Limes cream and balm. Both the CF Lavender and 1445 performance is spectacular.

Ben

 

[brucered]

i have both soaps and both balms...i prefer the scent of the Lime ASB, but use the Lavender more due to more lavender soaps and it being a more neutral scent and easily accommodates a cologne or edt.

so my vote was for Lavender, even though I prefer the nice strong scent of the Lime. when i use the lime, i do not follow it with any cologne. it's got a very strong scent and i enjoy that aspect of it, and even the family gives it the thumbs up.

i'm switching to mainly splashes so neither are getting used much any more

 

[rum]

Thanks for the responses so far guys; they have given me lots to think about!!
Please keep them coming and do vote if you haven't already done so.

 

[rum]

Now the Limes is overtaking the Lavender.... What's your justification people?

 

[Tummers09]

I vote lavender.

You can smell like lavender. I'll smell like limes.