ouch said:Get your Fenix and Arc yet?
Yup, and I have one more biggie on the way to replace an old Maglite we use to check the horses when trail camping. Sigh... I was looking for a AAA LED backup light to carry everyday and use as a backup for hiking as my headlamp (PT Eos) also takes AAAs. It is easier to carry a single battery type when backpacking. My unenlightened thoughts...
The weights and sizes are very close to each other (important as a backpacker). The Arc has a 0.5W Nichia LED whereas the L0P has the 1W Luxeon (as you know), thus they even though they are both AAA LEDs, they are not at all a similar light in that regard.
The Arc just oozed quality - it is an outstanding light, built like a tank, solid, beautiful. The Fenix is mass produced (the first mass produced 1W Luxeon apparently) and just felt "cheap" compared to the Arc, but that is an unfair statement in a way. There is no comparison on brightness - that 1W bulb in the Fenix just blows away the Nichia 0.5W in the Arc. But, there are some important differences. The Arc is regulated which is important to me, and it has incredible run time - 15 hours off an alkaline AAA. The Fenix is hot and bright and runs through batteries like a fat kid eating Twinkies at about 1.5 hours burn, plus it is not a regulated light.
The brightness of the Arc is more than sufficient for an EDC light and too much brightness when backpacking is often just overkill. When I carried a multistage regulated headlamp that I tested (PT Corona), it has 8 0.5W Nichias in it and has 4 main power levels with each level has a half power modulated to it for 8 brighness levels. In bckpacking, you never use the full power - the bottom four levels are more than enough so the extra is just, well, extra.
The Fenix is now in my wife's purse so she has an emergency light and the Arc is on my keychain, but I would like to carry it in a different spot as it is not the handiest place.
Whew -
Dennis