You did a fine job! I've had to do it before too in some special cases. Sometimes I actually think it looks better as it helps make things look a bit more sleek. Clean cuts are they key, you did a nice job with it.Yes sir, i had cut the band just a sliver on each side. I looked and looked for a 23mm rally strap and couldn't find one on Amazon or etsy.. So I had to get the 24mm